supplementary materials


Acta Cryst. (2009). E65, m759-m760    [ doi:10.1107/S1600536809021527 ]

Tetraphenylarsonium cis-bis[1,2-bis(trifluoromethyl)ethene-1,2-dithiolato]platinate(II)

S. Hosking, A. J. Lough and U. Fekl

Abstract top

In the title compound, (C24H20As)[Pt(C4F6S2)2], the cation lies on a twofold rotation axis while the anion has crystallographic inversion symmetry. The PtII ion is in a slightly distorted square-planar coordination environment. The F atoms of both unique -CF3 groups are disordered over two sets of sites, the ratios of refined occupancies being 0.677 (15):0.323 (15) and 0.640 (16):0.360 (16). The crystal structure is the first to date of a monoanionic [Pt(tfd)2]- species [tfd is 1,2-bis(trifluoromethyl)ethene-1,2-dithiolate] with a non-redox-active cation.

Comment top

Square-planar metal bisdithiolene compounds are of fundamental importance for our understanding of metal complexes containing non-innocent ligands (Ray et al., 2005). The nickel complex [Ni(tfd)2] (tfd = S2C2(CF3)2) has received considerable attention due to its potential applicability in ethylene separation and purification (Wang & Stiefel, 2001). The one-electron reduced form of the metal complex is involved in the mechanism of alkene binding (Harrison et al., 2006). In the course of our studies on the analogous platinum complexes we have crystallographically characterized [Pt(tfd)2]0 and [Pt(tfd)2]2- (Kogut et al., 2006; Tang et al., 2009, respectively). These complexes contain square-planar platinum(II), and the tfd ligand is redox-active. While tfd is not fully reduced in the charge-neutral complex (and is only formally 1,2-perfluoromethylethene-1,2-dithiolate), tfd is fully reduced in the dianion. The C—C bond in the chelate ring of the neutral complex shortens upon reduction (Tang et al., 2009).

We report here on the first crystal structure of monoanionic [Pt(tfd)2]- with a non-redox-active cation (Fig. 1). A report on a previous structural determination (Kasper & Interrante, 1976) of the charge-transfer complex between tetrathiofulvalene and charge-neutral [Pt(tfd)2] has proposed that [Pt(tfd)2] is reduced by one electron and tetrathiovulvalene is oxidized to tetrathiafulvalinium; however, in order to reliably establish the structural properties of the one-electron-reduced species, use of a non-redox-active cation is preferable. [Pt(tfd)2] in the title compound reported here is clearly monoanionic. The structure reported here completes structural characterization of the redox series [Pt(tfd)2]0/1-/2-. Structural features of [Pt(tfd)2]- (Fig. 2) are intermediate with respect to those of [Pt(tfd)2]0 (Kogut et al., 2006) and [Pt(tfd)2]2- (Tang et al., 2009). The structural effects observed upon stepwise reduction of the neutral complex [Pt(tfd)2]0 to [Pt(tfd)2]- and [Pt(tfd)2]2- are of varying statistical significance (significant within 2σ for Pt—S, borderline significant for C—C). However, they confirm observations made by Lim et al. (2001) on an analogous nickel complex containing a non-fluorinated dithiolene, the redox series [Ni(S2C2Me2)2]0,1-,2-. The combined evidence suggests that these effects are real. A relatively straightforward rationalization, in terms of resonance structures, is shown in Fig. 2. For a detailed description of the electronic structure of metal dithiolene complexes, see Kirk et al. (2004).

Related literature top

For background information, see: Ray et al. (2005); Wang & Stiefel (2001); Harrison et al. (2006). For related crystal structures, see: Kogut et al. (2006); Tang et al. (2009); Kasper & Interrante (1976); Lim et al. (2001). For synthetic details, see: Davison et al. (1964). For the treatment of disordered solvent of crystallization, see: Spek, 2009; Stähler et al. (2001); Cox et al. (2003); Mohamed et al. (2003); Athimoolam et al. (2005). For a detailed description of the electronic structure of metal–dithiolene complexes, see: Kirk et al. (2004).

Experimental top

The tetraphenylarsonium salt of [Pt(tfd)2]- was synthesized using a slightly modified literature procedure. The literature procedure uses acetone/ethanol as the reductant, followed by precipitation with tetraphenylarsonium chloride, (Davison et al., 1964) to obtain the product in 36% yield. We repeated that literature reaction and obtained 24% yield. We then decided to use water in THF to achieve reduction of [Pt(tfd)2], followed by addition of tetraphenylarsonium chloride. It was previously observed that water in polar solvents such as THF leads to reduction of the related nickel complex Ni[(S2C2(CF3)2]2 (Harrison et al., 2006). In a 10 ml vial, 24.9 mg (0.0385 mmol) of [Pt(tfd)2] were dissolved in 1.0 ml ofTHF, leading to a dark greenish-blue solution. Addition of 0.3 ml of H2O induced a rapid colour change, to produce a brownish-yellow solution. Solid tetraphenylarsonium chloride (25.3 mg, 0.068 mmol) was added to the solution while stirring, followed by an additional 0.25 ml of THF, to produce a homogeneous solution. In order to lower the solubility of the salt again, an additional 0.4 ml of H2O were added, and the vial was storred at 278 K for three weeks. Crystals had not formed at that time, and crystallization was induced by scratching of the inner surface of the vial with a glass rod. After three additional weeks at 378 K, [AsPh4]+[Pt(tfd)2]- had crystallized as dark yellow blocks. The crystals were removed from the supernatant and dried under vacuum. Yield: 26.6 mg (0.0258 mmol, 67%). Inspections of the crystals with a stereomicroscope showed them to be of excellent quality. One crystal was chosen for the single-crystal X-ray structure determination.

Refinement top

H atoms were placed in calculated positions and treated as riding: C—H = 0.95 Å with Uiso(H) = 1.2Uiso(C). The F atoms of both unique –CF3 groups are disordered over two sets of sites with the ratio of refined occupancies being 0.677 (15):0.323 (15) for F1/F2/F3:F1A/F2A/F3A and 0.640 (16):0.360 (16) for F4/F5/F6:F4A/F5A/F6A. The SADI and EADP commands in the SHELXTL (Sheldrick, 2008) software were used to restrain the parameters of the disordered groups. During the refinement of the structure, electron density peaks were located that were believed to be highly disordered solvent molecules (possibly THF). Attempts made to model the solvent molecule were not successful. The SQUEEZE option in PLATON (Spek, 2009) indicated there was a solvent cavity of volume 130.0 Å3 containing approximately 18 electrons. In the final cycles of refinement, this contribution to the electron density was removed from the observed data. The density, the F(000) value, the molecular weight and the formula are given without taking into account the results obtained with the SQUEEZE option PLATON (Spek, 2009). Similar treatments of disordered solvent molecules have been carried out in this manner (Stähler et al., 2001; Cox et al., 2003; Mohamed et al., 2003; Athimoolam et al., 2005).

Computing details top

Data collection: COLLECT (Nonius, 2002); cell refinement: DENZO–SMN (Otwinowski & Minor, 1997); data reduction: DENZO–SMN (Otwinowski & Minor, 1997); program(s) used to solve structure: SHELXS97 (Sheldrick, 2008); program(s) used to refine structure: SHELXL97 (Sheldrick, 2008); molecular graphics: ORTEP-3 (Farrugia, 1997); software used to prepare material for publication: SHELXTL (Sheldrick, 2008).

Figures top
[Figure 1] Fig. 1. A view of the molecular structure of the title compound. Displacement ellipsoids are drawn at the 30% probabilty level. For the cation and anion, the primed labels are related by the symmetry operators (-x, y, -z + 1/2) and (-x + 1/2, -y + 1/2, -z + 1), respectively.
[Figure 2] Fig. 2. Comparison of the structural features of [Pt(tfd)2]0 (Kogut et al.,2006), [Pt(tfd)2]- (this work) and [Pt(tfd)2]2- (Tang et al., 2009).
Tetraphenylarsonium cis-bis[1,2-bis(trifluoromethyl)ethene-1,2-dithiolato]platinate(II) top
Crystal data top
(C24H20As)[Pt(C4F6S2)2]F(000) = 1980
Mr = 1030.76Dx = 1.789 Mg m3
Monoclinic, C2/cMo Kα radiation, λ = 0.71073 Å
Hall symbol: -C 2ycCell parameters from 13097 reflections
a = 24.9649 (10) Åθ = 2.9–27.5°
b = 7.3189 (3) ŵ = 4.82 mm1
c = 23.6773 (6) ÅT = 150 K
β = 117.779 (2)°Block, orange
V = 3827.6 (2) Å30.24 × 0.21 × 0.16 mm
Z = 4
Data collection top
Nonius KappaCCD
diffractometer
4282 independent reflections
Radiation source: fine-focus sealed tube3269 reflections with I > 2σ(I)
graphiteRint = 0.051
Detector resolution: 9 pixels mm-1θmax = 27.5°, θmin = 2.9°
φ scans and ω scans with κ offsetsh = 3225
Absorption correction: multi-scan
(SORTAV; Blessing, 1995)
k = 89
Tmin = 0.341, Tmax = 0.471l = 2530
13097 measured reflections
Refinement top
Refinement on F2Primary atom site location: structure-invariant direct methods
Least-squares matrix: fullSecondary atom site location: difference Fourier map
R[F2 > 2σ(F2)] = 0.054Hydrogen site location: inferred from neighbouring sites
wR(F2) = 0.156H-atom parameters constrained
S = 1.09 w = 1/[σ2(Fo2) + (0.0976P)2 + 3.8529P]
where P = (Fo2 + 2Fc2)/3
4282 reflections(Δ/σ)max < 0.001
230 parametersΔρmax = 4.18 e Å3
60 restraintsΔρmin = 2.83 e Å3
Crystal data top
(C24H20As)[Pt(C4F6S2)2]V = 3827.6 (2) Å3
Mr = 1030.76Z = 4
Monoclinic, C2/cMo Kα radiation
a = 24.9649 (10) ŵ = 4.82 mm1
b = 7.3189 (3) ÅT = 150 K
c = 23.6773 (6) Å0.24 × 0.21 × 0.16 mm
β = 117.779 (2)°
Data collection top
Nonius KappaCCD
diffractometer
4282 independent reflections
Absorption correction: multi-scan
(SORTAV; Blessing, 1995)
3269 reflections with I > 2σ(I)
Tmin = 0.341, Tmax = 0.471Rint = 0.051
13097 measured reflectionsθmax = 27.5°
Refinement top
R[F2 > 2σ(F2)] = 0.054H-atom parameters constrained
wR(F2) = 0.156Δρmax = 4.18 e Å3
S = 1.09Δρmin = 2.83 e Å3
4282 reflectionsAbsolute structure: ?
230 parametersFlack parameter: ?
60 restraintsRogers parameter: ?
Special details top

Geometry. All e.s.d.'s (except the e.s.d. in the dihedral angle between two l.s. planes) are estimated using the full covariance matrix. The cell e.s.d.'s are taken into account individually in the estimation of e.s.d.'s in distances, angles and torsion angles; correlations between e.s.d.'s in cell parameters are only used when they are defined by crystal symmetry. An approximate (isotropic) treatment of cell e.s.d.'s is used for estimating e.s.d.'s involving l.s. planes.

Refinement. Refinement of F2 against ALL reflections. The weighted R-factor wR and goodness of fit S are based on F2, conventional R-factors R are based on F, with F set to zero for negative F2. The threshold expression of F2 > σ(F2) is used only for calculating R-factors(gt) etc. and is not relevant to the choice of reflections for refinement. R-factors based on F2 are statistically about twice as large as those based on F, and R- factors based on ALL data will be even larger.

Fractional atomic coordinates and isotropic or equivalent isotropic displacement parameters (Å2) top
xyzUiso*/UeqOcc. (<1)
Pt10.25000.25000.50000.02912 (17)
S10.22659 (8)0.5216 (3)0.44973 (9)0.0371 (4)
S20.30913 (9)0.1915 (3)0.45362 (10)0.0408 (5)
F10.2074 (3)0.7827 (10)0.3529 (5)0.061 (2)0.676 (15)
F20.3033 (3)0.8005 (11)0.3897 (5)0.061 (2)0.676 (15)
F30.2523 (3)0.6463 (10)0.3070 (3)0.061 (2)0.676 (15)
F1A0.2129 (6)0.680 (3)0.3037 (4)0.078 (7)*0.324 (15)
F2A0.2298 (8)0.795 (2)0.3910 (9)0.071 (6)*0.324 (15)
F3A0.2988 (6)0.796 (2)0.3648 (8)0.061 (6)*0.324 (15)
F40.3847 (4)0.2453 (10)0.3995 (4)0.062 (2)0.638 (16)
F50.3645 (4)0.5234 (10)0.3690 (4)0.062 (2)0.638 (16)
F60.3084 (3)0.3029 (13)0.3109 (3)0.062 (2)0.638 (16)
F6A0.2985 (6)0.440 (3)0.3141 (6)0.092 (7)*0.362 (16)
F4A0.3588 (9)0.212 (2)0.3578 (12)0.137 (12)*0.362 (16)
F5A0.3837 (5)0.4871 (18)0.3956 (7)0.068 (6)*0.362 (16)
C10.2649 (3)0.5226 (11)0.4045 (3)0.0394 (17)
C20.3007 (4)0.3803 (12)0.4073 (4)0.0438 (19)
C30.2566 (3)0.6806 (13)0.3656 (3)0.059 (2)
C40.3370 (3)0.3656 (8)0.3723 (3)0.059 (2)
As10.00000.61646 (13)0.25000.0248 (2)
C110.0654 (3)0.4612 (9)0.2596 (3)0.0261 (13)
C120.0908 (3)0.4759 (10)0.2191 (3)0.0367 (16)
H12A0.07670.56580.18640.044*
C130.1372 (3)0.3578 (12)0.2266 (4)0.0415 (19)
H13A0.15500.36740.19890.050*
C140.1573 (4)0.2281 (10)0.2733 (5)0.041 (2)
H14A0.18920.14830.27810.049*
C150.1313 (4)0.2115 (11)0.3144 (4)0.0393 (19)
H15A0.14550.12110.34690.047*
C160.0849 (3)0.3278 (11)0.3071 (3)0.0348 (16)
H16A0.06650.31700.33410.042*
C210.0245 (3)0.7717 (8)0.1779 (3)0.0254 (14)
C220.0166 (3)0.9043 (10)0.1792 (3)0.0302 (15)
H22A0.05630.91040.21410.036*
C230.0014 (3)1.0262 (10)0.1288 (3)0.0354 (16)
H23A0.02601.11590.12860.042*
C240.0600 (4)1.0162 (11)0.0784 (4)0.0425 (18)
H24A0.07221.09990.04390.051*
C250.1002 (3)0.8881 (12)0.0776 (3)0.0426 (19)
H25A0.14010.88380.04300.051*
C260.0826 (3)0.7638 (9)0.1277 (4)0.0333 (17)
H26A0.11030.67440.12740.040*
Atomic displacement parameters (Å2) top
U11U22U33U12U13U23
Pt10.0227 (2)0.0289 (2)0.0304 (2)0.00284 (14)0.00796 (18)0.00095 (14)
S10.0276 (9)0.0297 (10)0.0446 (10)0.0037 (7)0.0090 (8)0.0038 (8)
S20.0384 (11)0.0366 (10)0.0520 (12)0.0004 (9)0.0248 (9)0.0049 (9)
F10.053 (3)0.061 (3)0.075 (4)0.007 (2)0.035 (3)0.029 (3)
F20.053 (3)0.061 (3)0.075 (4)0.007 (2)0.035 (3)0.029 (3)
F30.053 (3)0.061 (3)0.075 (4)0.007 (2)0.035 (3)0.029 (3)
F40.056 (4)0.080 (5)0.066 (4)0.015 (3)0.042 (3)0.001 (3)
F50.056 (4)0.080 (5)0.066 (4)0.015 (3)0.042 (3)0.001 (3)
F60.056 (4)0.080 (5)0.066 (4)0.015 (3)0.042 (3)0.001 (3)
C10.034 (4)0.036 (4)0.037 (4)0.014 (3)0.007 (3)0.001 (3)
C20.047 (4)0.040 (5)0.045 (4)0.019 (4)0.021 (4)0.014 (4)
C30.056 (6)0.062 (6)0.056 (6)0.021 (5)0.023 (5)0.001 (5)
C40.073 (7)0.055 (6)0.056 (5)0.009 (5)0.036 (5)0.009 (4)
As10.0215 (5)0.0261 (5)0.0256 (5)0.0000.0099 (4)0.000
C110.020 (3)0.026 (3)0.031 (3)0.001 (3)0.010 (3)0.010 (3)
C120.042 (4)0.036 (4)0.036 (4)0.009 (3)0.021 (3)0.003 (3)
C130.035 (4)0.055 (6)0.042 (4)0.008 (4)0.025 (3)0.002 (4)
C140.028 (4)0.032 (5)0.061 (6)0.006 (3)0.018 (4)0.010 (3)
C150.028 (4)0.038 (4)0.037 (4)0.002 (3)0.002 (3)0.002 (3)
C160.031 (4)0.034 (4)0.041 (4)0.004 (3)0.018 (3)0.005 (3)
C210.020 (3)0.028 (4)0.027 (3)0.000 (2)0.010 (3)0.002 (2)
C220.026 (3)0.033 (4)0.027 (3)0.004 (3)0.009 (3)0.002 (3)
C230.035 (4)0.030 (4)0.040 (4)0.001 (3)0.016 (3)0.011 (3)
C240.054 (5)0.039 (5)0.037 (4)0.007 (4)0.023 (4)0.009 (3)
C250.031 (4)0.054 (5)0.031 (4)0.008 (4)0.004 (3)0.009 (4)
C260.019 (3)0.043 (5)0.034 (4)0.003 (3)0.009 (3)0.005 (3)
Geometric parameters (Å, °) top
Pt1—S1i2.2496 (18)As1—C111.913 (6)
Pt1—S12.2496 (19)C11—C121.378 (9)
Pt1—S2i2.254 (2)C11—C161.394 (10)
Pt1—S22.254 (2)C12—C131.390 (10)
S1—C11.737 (8)C12—H12A0.9500
S2—C21.715 (9)C13—C141.364 (12)
F1—C31.346 (7)C13—H13A0.9500
F2—C31.355 (6)C14—C151.402 (13)
F3—C31.365 (6)C14—H14A0.9500
F1A—C31.360 (7)C15—C161.382 (11)
F2A—C31.372 (7)C15—H15A0.9500
F3A—C31.359 (7)C16—H16A0.9500
F4—C41.376 (6)C21—C261.382 (10)
F5—C41.365 (6)C21—C221.403 (9)
F6—C41.366 (6)C22—C231.386 (10)
F6A—C41.371 (6)C22—H22A0.9500
F4A—C41.360 (6)C23—C241.394 (11)
F5A—C41.362 (6)C23—H23A0.9500
C1—C21.353 (12)C24—C251.368 (11)
C1—C31.432 (13)C24—H24A0.9500
C2—C41.489 (12)C25—C261.394 (11)
As1—C21ii1.899 (7)C25—H25A0.9500
As1—C211.899 (7)C26—H26A0.9500
As1—C11ii1.913 (6)
S1i—Pt1—S1180.00 (10)C21ii—As1—C11110.4 (3)
S1i—Pt1—S2i88.73 (8)C21—As1—C11111.2 (3)
S1—Pt1—S2i91.27 (8)C11ii—As1—C11107.1 (4)
S1i—Pt1—S291.27 (8)C12—C11—C16120.9 (6)
S1—Pt1—S288.73 (8)C12—C11—As1121.0 (5)
S2i—Pt1—S2180.000 (1)C16—C11—As1118.0 (5)
C1—S1—Pt1104.3 (3)C11—C12—C13119.4 (7)
C2—S2—Pt1104.2 (3)C11—C12—H12A120.3
C2—C1—C3123.2 (7)C13—C12—H12A120.3
C2—C1—S1120.5 (6)C14—C13—C12120.3 (7)
C3—C1—S1116.3 (6)C14—C13—H13A119.8
C1—C2—C4126.0 (7)C12—C13—H13A119.8
C1—C2—S2122.1 (6)C13—C14—C15120.6 (7)
C4—C2—S2111.9 (6)C13—C14—H14A119.7
F1—C3—F2104.5 (7)C15—C14—H14A119.7
F3A—C3—F1A102.9 (8)C16—C15—C14119.4 (8)
F1—C3—F3104.1 (7)C16—C15—H15A120.3
F2—C3—F3101.0 (6)C14—C15—H15A120.3
F3A—C3—F2A99.4 (7)C15—C16—C11119.3 (7)
F1A—C3—F2A99.5 (7)C15—C16—H16A120.3
F1—C3—C1115.9 (7)C11—C16—H16A120.3
F2—C3—C1114.5 (7)C26—C21—C22120.8 (6)
F1A—C3—C1119.6 (10)C26—C21—As1121.1 (5)
F3—C3—C1115.2 (7)C22—C21—As1117.9 (5)
F2A—C3—C199.6 (11)C23—C22—C21119.1 (6)
F4A—C4—F5A105.9 (8)C23—C22—H22A120.5
F5—C4—F6104.5 (6)C21—C22—H22A120.5
F4A—C4—F6A104.3 (8)C22—C23—C24119.5 (7)
F5A—C4—F6A102.4 (7)C22—C23—H23A120.2
F5—C4—F4102.7 (6)C24—C23—H23A120.2
F6—C4—F4101.1 (6)C25—C24—C23121.3 (7)
F4A—C4—C2128.2 (13)C25—C24—H24A119.4
F5A—C4—C2110.8 (9)C23—C24—H24A119.4
F5—C4—C2115.0 (6)C24—C25—C26119.8 (7)
F6—C4—C2117.8 (7)C24—C25—H25A120.1
F6A—C4—C2102.1 (10)C26—C25—H25A120.1
F4—C4—C2113.8 (7)C21—C26—C25119.5 (7)
C21ii—As1—C21106.5 (4)C21—C26—H26A120.2
C21ii—As1—C11ii111.2 (3)C25—C26—H26A120.2
C21—As1—C11ii110.4 (3)
Symmetry codes: (i) −x+1/2, −y+1/2, −z+1; (ii) −x, y, −z+1/2.
Acknowledgements top

Funding by the Natural Science and Engineering Research Council (NSERC) of Canada, the Canadian Foundation for Innovation, the Ontario Research Fund, the Ontario Innovation Trust and the University of Toronto is gratefully acknowledged. We thank Mr Dan Harrison (University of Toronto) for assistance in the steps leading to the reduction of [Pt(tfd)2].

references
References top

Athimoolam, S., Kumar, J., Ramakrishnan, V. & Rajaram, R. K. (2005). Acta Cryst. E61, m2014–m2017.

Blessing, R. H. (1995). Acta Cryst. A51, 33–38.

Cox, P. J., Kumarasamy, Y., Nahar, L., Sarker, S. D. & Shoeb, M. (2003). Acta Cryst. E59, o975–o977.

Davison, A., Edelstein, N., Holm, R. H. & Maki, A. H. (1964). Inorg. Chem. 3, 814–823.

Farrugia, L. J. (1997). J. Appl. Cryst. 30, 565.

Harrison, D. J., Nguyen, N., Lough, A. J. & Fekl, U. (2006). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 128, 11026–11027.

Kasper, J. S. & Interrante, L. V. (1976). Acta Cryst. B32, 2914–2916.

Kirk, M. L., McNaughton, R. L. & Helton, M. E. (2004). Prog. Inorg. Chem. 52, 111–209.

Kogut, E., Tang, J. A., Lough, A. J., Widdifield, C. M., Schurko, R. W. & Fekl, U. (2006). Inorg. Chem. 45, 8850–8852.

Lim, B. S., Fomitchev, D. V. & Holm, R. H. (2001). Inorg. Chem. 40, 4257–4262.

Mohamed, A. A., Krause Bauer, J. A., Bruce, A. E. & Bruce, M. R. M. (2003). Acta Cryst. C59, m84–m86.

Nonius (2002). COLLECT. Nonius BV , Delft, The Netherlands.

Otwinowski, Z. & Minor, W. (1997). Methods in Enzymology, Vol. 276, Macromolecular Crystallography, Part A, edited by C. W. Carter Jr & R. M. Sweet, pp. 307–326. New York: Academic Press.

Ray, K., Weyhermüller, T., Neese, F. & Wieghardt, K. (2005). Inorg. Chem. 44, 5345–5360.

Sheldrick, G. M. (2008). Acta Cryst. A64, 112–122.

Spek, A. L. (2009). Acta Cryst. D65, 148–155.

Stähler, R., Näther, C. & Bensch, W. (2001). Acta Cryst. C57, 26–27.

Tang, J. E., Kogut, E., Norton, D., Lough, A. J., McGarvey, B. R., Fekl, U. & Schurko, R. W. (2009). J. Phys. Chem. B, 113, 3298–3313.

Wang, K. & Stiefel, E. I. (2001). Science, 291, 106–109.