Figure 3
Radiation-damage model. The observations made by Owen et al. (2006 ) and Kmetko et al. (2006 ) are reproduced with permission from the original publishers and plotted against predicted curves derived from two alternative radiation-damage models. The `H model' is an exponential decay of spot intensity with dose and the `B model' is the dose-dependent B-factor model suggested by Kmetko et al. (2006 ). The `H model' predictions were made by applying (13) to intensities derived from the observed structure-factor file deposited with the indicated PDB entry and then computing the sum of all intensities (a) followed by scaling the `simulated damage' intensities to the `zero-dose' intensities (b) using the procedure described by Kmetko et al. (2006 ). The `B model' prediction curves (dotted lines) were prepared similarly except that the `simulated damage' intensities were generated by applying the relevant dose-dependent B factor reported by Kmetko et al. (2006 ). All `H model' curves (solid lines) used the same value of H (10 MGy Å−1) and therefore may explain the dissimilar `sensitivity parameter' observed by Kmetko et al. (2006 ) for apoferritin and lysozyme (orange circles versus blue squares, respectively). It is clear from (a) that the `B model' is at odds with the observations of Owen et al. (2006 ) (green diamonds), although the same predicted intensities are in very good agreement with the data points from Kmetko et al. (2006 ) (orange circles). Agreement between these two studies is restored, however, if we accept the `H model' where the resolution-dependence of radiation damage is exponential as opposed to a Gaussian (B model). |