review page for submission xx5048

Stage - 1 - 2 - 3 - 4 - 5 -

Article review stage


Small-angle X-ray scattering paper
Peter Busch, Markus Jones, David Smith and Christine M. Hope	Notes for authors Notes for referees

Current version received on 15 May 2005 22:51:37 BST

Referee's report

Please review this article bearing in mind the questions below and the Notes for referees. Your comments should be given in the form below. This report page is provided for your convenience: if preferred, your report may be returned by email.
When you have finished, click on submit to send your report to the Co-editor.

Publication recommendation
Is the paper worthy of publication?
yes, as it is   yes, with minor revision   yes, with major revision   no, not at all

Impact
What do you think the impact of the article will be? high   medium   low

Technical quality
Is the work technically sound? yes   no
Does the evidence presented justify the conclusions drawn?  yes   no
If you have answered no to either question, please comment in the form below.

Presentation
Could the presentation be more efficient?yes   no
Can any material be omitted or deposited?yes   no
Should any additional graphics/multimedia be included?yes   no
If you have answered yes to any of these questions, please comment in the form below.

Journal
Is the choice of journal correct? yes   no
If not, please specify a more appropriate journal:Notes for authors
Have the requirements of Notes for authors been met? yes   no
If not, please comment in the form below.

Literature
Is the literature adequately cited? yes   no
If not, please comment in the form below.