research papers\(\def\hfill{\hskip 5em}\def\hfil{\hskip 3em}\def\eqno#1{\hfil {#1}}\)

Journal logoSTRUCTURAL
CHEMISTRY
ISSN: 2053-2296

The disordered structure of sparsentan: energy calculations for com­peting chain con­for­mations

crossmark logo

aChristian Doppler Laboratory for Advanced Crystal Engineering Strategies in Drug Development, Innrain 52c, Innsbruck, 6020, Austria, and bInstitute of Pharmacy, University of Innsbruck, Innrain 52c, Innsbruck, 6020, Austria
*Correspondence e-mail: [email protected], [email protected]

Edited by X. Wang, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, USA (Received 17 June 2025; accepted 12 August 2025; online 26 August 2025)

The crystalline form of sparsentan (SST) (systematic name: 2-{4-[(2-butyl-4-oxo-1,3-di­aza­spiro­[4.4]non-1-en-3-yl)meth­yl]-2-(eth­oxy­meth­yl)phen­yl}-N-(4,5-dimethyl-1,2-oxazol-3-yl)benzene­sulfonamide), C32H40N4O5S, was produced and characterized using single-crystal and powder X-ray diffraction, differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) and IR spectroscopy. The SST mol­ecule displays positional disorder in three different sections. Viability tests of alternative disorder models involved the calculation of energetic contributions to analyse each possible mol­ecular con­for­mation within its crystal environment and identify the energetically most favourable con­for­mations in the lattice.

1. Introduction

Sparsentan (SST, Scheme 1[link]) is a dual endothelin type A (ETA) receptor and angiotensin II type 1 (AT1) receptor antagonist (DEARA), developed by Travere Therapeutics and marketed under the brand name Filspari. It is used for the treatment of IgA nephropathy and focal segmental glomerulosclerosis (FSGS) (Syed, 2023View full citation; Zhang et al., 2020View full citation). By blocking the ETA receptor, this drug reduces vasoconstriction, inflammation and fibrosis, while its AT1 receptor antagonism lowers blood pressure and protects kidney function. This dual mechanism is effective for treating kidney diseases, such as focal segmental glomerulosclerosis (FSGS) and IgA nephropathy (IgAN), as proteinuria is reduced and disease progression slowed (Kohan et al., 2024View full citation). The SST mol­ecule is highly flexible and contains seven hy­dro­gen-bond acceptors, one hy­dro­gen-bond donor and 12 torsion angles (Murugesan et al., 2002View full citation). Its mol­ecular flexibility predisposes sparsentan to the formation of an amorphous phase (Macikenas et al., 2019View full citation). An amorphous phase typically dissolves faster than its stable crystalline counterpart, but is generally less stable over time, which can potentially lead to performance variability (Desiraju, 2007View full citation). Although limited structural data for this phase have been disclosed (Murugesan et al., 2005View full citation), the detailed structural and con­for­mational information which are necessary to understand its properties and behaviour have not been available so far. Therefore, we have carried out a com­prehensive crystallographic study to establish the solid-state characteristics of the SST mol­ecule.

Flexible mol­ecules can adopt a range of energetically viable con­for­mations whose specific crystal packing preferences may then result in the formation of polymorphs, i.e. a single mol­ecule crystallizes in multiple crystal forms with distinct mol­ecular packing arrangements and physical properties (Tang et al., 2021View full citation). The study of flexible mol­ecules is therefore an important topic in materials science, pharmaceutical research and crystal engineering. In addition, mol­ecular flexibility may also be linked with the observation of structural disorder in certain crystals. Many mol­ecular crystals and more than 20% of the crystal structures deposited in the Cambridge Structural Database (CSD) exhibit some form of disorder (Groom et al., 2016View full citation; Linden, 2023View full citation). The accurate refinement of these structures depends critically on the available diffraction data, as only high-quality data enable a reliable determination of the mol­ecular geometry and a sufficient resolution of the disordered regions, and weak data will lead to inferior results (Diederichs, 2016View full citation). In this context, energy calculations that are aimed at identifying the energetically most favourable con­for­mations within the lattice have become a valuable tool for a more reliable disorder refinement. For instance, energy minimization techniques like the `mol­ecule-in-cluster' approach allow the analysis of each of the possible mol­ecular con­for­mations within its crystal environment, refining the model based on the most stable con­for­mations (Dittrich, 2021View full citation). By com­putationally optimizing each mol­ecular arrangement and applying targeted restraints, the alignment between the model and the experimental data is improved, and thus the accuracy and precision of disorder refinement in structural analysis is enhanced (Müller, 2021View full citation). In the present study, the crystal structure refinement revealed multiple disordered fragments within the SST mol­ecule. Advanced techniques, including energy calculations (Clark et al., 2005View full citation), were applied to assess the viability of alternative disorder geometries and also to evaluate which of these are likely to co-exist in individual mol­ecules.

[Scheme 1]

2. Experimental

2.1. Materials

Amorphous SST was obtained from Taros Chemicals. This substance was recrystallized prior to use in further experiments (details of the recrystallization method are provided below). Analytical grade solvents were procured from com­mercial suppliers.

2.2. Preparation of crystalline SST

Amorphous SST (1 g) was dissolved in 5 ml of iso­propanol and 5 ml of water was added dropwise to the mixture. The resulting mixture was then warmed to 40 °C to produce a clear solution. This solution was allowed to cool and kept at room tem­per­a­ture, resulting in the formation of white prismatic crystals suitable for single-crystal structure determination. These crystals were filtered off, washed with a small amount of a 2:1 iso­propanol–water mixture and dried to yield a white crystalline solid.

2.3. Single-crystal structure refinement

Crystal data, data collection and structure refinement details are summarized in Table 1[link]. All H atoms, except for those in disordered fragments, were identified in difference maps. Methyl H atoms were idealized and included as rigid groups allowed to rotate but not tip (C—H = 0.98 Å), with Uiso(H) parameters set to 1.5Ueq(C) of the parent atom. H atoms bonded to secondary CH2 and tertiary CH atoms (C—H = 0.99 Å), and H atoms in aromatic groups (C—H = 0.95 Å) were positioned geometrically, with Uiso(H) values set to 1.2Ueq(C) of the parent atom. The H atom of the NH group was refined with a restrained bond length [N6—H6 = 0.88 (1) Å] and its Uiso(H) parameter was refined freely.

Table 1
Experimental details

Crystal data
Chemical formula C32H40N4O5S
Mr 592.74
Crystal system, space group Triclinic, PMathematical equation
Temperature (K) 193
a, b, c (Å) 11.3363 (10), 11.8815 (8), 14.0763 (10)
α, β, γ (°) 98.113 (6), 112.679 (8), 110.711 (7)
V3) 1549.4 (2)
Z 2
Radiation type Mo Kα
μ (mm−1) 0.15
Crystal size (mm) 0.25 × 0.25 × 0.15
 
Data collection
Diffractometer Rigaku Xcalibur Gemini ultra diffractometer with a Ruby detector
Absorption correction Multi-scan (CrysAlis PRO; Rigaku OD, 2020View full citation)
Tmin, Tmax 0.921, 1.000
No. of measured, independent and observed [I > 2σ(I)] reflections 14469, 6837, 4250
Rint 0.042
(sin θ/λ)max−1) 0.641
 
Refinement
R[F2 > 2σ(F2)], wR(F2), S 0.054, 0.140, 1.03
No. of reflections 6837
No. of parameters 528
No. of restraints 483
H-atom treatment H atoms treated by a mixture of independent and constrained refinement
Δρmax, Δρmin (e Å−3) 0.48, −0.31
Computer programs: CrysAlis PRO (Rigaku OD, 2020View full citation), SHELXT (Sheldrick, 2015aView full citation), SHELXL2014 (Sheldrick, 2015bView full citation) and XP (Bruker, 1998View full citation).

Several sections of the SST mol­ecule were found to exhibit positional disorder, i.e. the butyl group (–C39—C40—C41—C42; labelled A in Scheme 1[link]), the eth­oxy­methyl group (–C24—O25—C26—C27; labelled B) and the cyclo­pentyl ring (C34–C37; labelled C). A combination of restraints on chemically equivalent 1,2- and 1,3-distances, and restraints on anisotropic displacement parameters was applied in the refinement of the non-H-atom positions in the disordered parts of the mol­ecules. The refined final occupancies were A1/A2 = 0.804 (5):0.196 (5), B1/B2/B3 = 0.597 (3):0.223 (3):0.180 (2) and C1/C2 = 0.571 (18):0.429 (18). A detailed description of the disorder model is given in Section 3.2[link] below.

2.4. Periodic electronic structure calculations

Six ordered structure models based on the disorder fragments in sections A and B of the SST mol­ecule (Scheme 1[link]) were generated. These models represented the initial configurations for periodic electronic structure optimization using CASTEP (Version 23.1; Clark et al., 2005View full citation) to generate optimized atomic positions and lattice parameters. The Perdew–Burke–Ernzerhof (PBE) generalized gradient approximation (GGA) exchange-correlation density functional (Perdew et al., 1996View full citation) was applied, along with ultrasoft pseudopotentials (Vanderbilt, 1990View full citation) and the MBD* semi-empirical dispersion correction (Tkatchenko et al., 2012View full citation). The k-point grid was chosen to maintain a maximum spacing of 2π × 0.07 Å−1, with a basis set cut-off energy of 780 eV. Convergence criteria were set to an energy precision better than 2 × 10−5 eV per atom, atomic displacements within 1 × 10−3, maximum forces below 1 × 10−3 Å and maximum stresses below 0.1 GPa. The main com­ponent of the cyclo­pentyl ring (section C in Scheme 1[link]) was used for all models, as the calculations were carried out to investigate the disordered chain con­for­mations.

2.5. Pairwise inter­molecular energy calculations

CrystalExplorer (Version 17; Mackenzie et al., 2017View full citation; Spack­man et al., 2021View full citation) and GAUSSIAN16 (Frisch et al., 2019View full citation) were used to calculate the pairwise inter­molecular energies for the PBE-MBD*-generated structure models of SST within a 3.80 Å radius, using the B3LYP/6-31G(d,p) wavefunction.

3. Results and discussion

3.1. Mol­ecular geometry and hy­dro­gen bonding

The asymmetric unit contains a single SST mol­ecule (Fig. 1[link]). The C12—C13—C18—C23 torsion angle, corresponding to the twist between the two central arene rings, is −69.7 (3)°. The C28—N29 bond is slightly out of the mean plane formed by atom C28 and the adjacent arene ring [C20—C21—C28—N29 = 14.6 (3)°], and the angle between the latter mean plane and that defined by atom C28 and the neighbouring imidazole ring (N29/C30/C31/N32/C33) is 82.33 (8)°. In the N-(1,2-oxazol-3-yl)benzene­sulfonamide fragment, the N2—C3 bond of the oxazole ring and the S7—C12 bond adopt a cis arrangement, and the central C3—N6—S7—C12 chain displays a gauche con­for­mation, corresponding to values of 3.2 (3), −60.5 (2) and −41.7 (2)° for the three essential torsion angles N2—C3—N6—S7 (τ1), C3—N6—S7—C12 (τ2) and N6—S7—C12—C13 (τ3). The most recent version of the Cambridge Structural Database (CSD, Version 6.00; Groom et al., 2016View full citation) contains another 67 examples of the same mol­ecular fragment in 55 different crystal structures, and the values of the torsion angles τ1τ3 (Fig. 2[link], inset) were collected for each of these examples (Table S1 of the supporting information). As two inversion-equivalent sets of torsions are present in each of these structures, the values of τ1, τ2 and τ3 were normalized so that τ2 ≥ 0° in order to facilitate a meaningful com­parison. The obtained geometrical parameters are listed in Table S1 of the sup­porting information. All values for the central angle τ2 lie within a narrow range between 50.1 and 86.1°, i.e. the central C—N—S—C chain is always gauche and its con­for­mational flexibility is small. Moreover, a plot of τ1 values against τ3 angles reveals two distinct densely populated clusters of data points in the narrow range 41.7 ≤ τ3 ≤ 86.5°. The corresponding τ1 values approach 180° in the first cluster (encircled in blue in Fig. 2[link]), indicating a trans orientation of the S—C bond relative to the N—C bond of the oxazole ring. By contrast, τ1 values are close to 0° in the second cluster (encircled in red in Fig. 2[link]), which corresponds to a cis con­for­mation and also contains the data point for SST. Therefore, the τ1 torsion describes a section of the mol­ecule which is typically planar and gives rise to two distinct geometries which are related by a 180° rotation about the central N—C bond.

[Figure 1]
Figure 1
The mol­ecular structure of SST, with displacement ellipsoids drawn at the 50% probability level and H atoms drawn as spheres of arbitrary size (minor disorder has been omitted for clarity).
[Figure 2]
Figure 2
Survey of the experimental con­for­mations of the N-(1,2-oxazol-3-yl)ben­zene­sulfonamide fragment characterized by torsion angles τ1τ3 (inset). The τ3 versus τ1 plot shows two clusters which correspond to preferred con­for­mations.

The SST mol­ecule contains seven potential acceptor sites for hy­dro­gen bonds and one hy­dro­gen-bond donor group, i.e. the NH group of the sulfonamide fragment. The latter forms an N6—H6⋯O11i inter­action with a sulfonyl O atom of a neighbouring mol­ecule (see Table 2[link] for symmetry codes). The resulting centrosymmetric dimer (Fig. 3[link]) displays an R22(6) ring (Etter et al., 1990View full citation; Bernstein et al., 1995View full citation). Within this dimer, there is also a short inter­molecular contact, C28—H28B⋯O8i, with an H⋯O separation of 2.46 Å, which involves the second sulfonyl O atom and the CH2 group linking the substituted imidazole ring with the arene ring (Table 2[link]). The same CH2 group is additionally engaged in a significant inter­action with the carbonyl group of a third mol­ecule, C28—H28A⋯O38ii, where the H⋯O distance is 2.40 Å.

Table 2
Hydrogen-bond geometry (Å, °)

D—H⋯A D—H H⋯A DA D—H⋯A
N6—H6⋯O11i 0.88 (1) 2.12 (1) 2.951 (2) 159 (2)
C28—H28A⋯O38ii 0.99 2.40 3.318 (3) 153
C28—H28B⋯O8i 0.99 2.46 3.265 (3) 138
Symmetry codes: (i) Mathematical equation; (ii) Mathematical equation.
[Figure 3]
Figure 3
N—H⋯O hy­dro­gen-bonded dimer (minor disorder and H atoms bonded to C atoms have been omitted for clarity). [Symmetry code: (i) −x + 1, −y + 1, −z + 1.]

3.2. Disorder model

In the case of the disordered B chain, the initial refinement was also carried out with a two-com­ponent model. The re­sulting disordered chain geometries displayed sensible 1,2- and 1,3-distances. The corresponding occupancy ratio was 0.7:0.3, R[F2 > 2σ(F2)] = 0.066 and wR(F2) = 0.205. However, this model displayed some unusual features, especially with regard to the position of the C27′ methyl group of the minor com­ponent (see Fig. S6 of the supporting information). In addition to an unexpected large spatial separation between alternative methyl-group positions (C27⋯C27′ = 1.94 Å), the C27′ methyl group was in close proximity to the C18–C23 ring of a second mol­ecule with C27′⋯C23iii = 2.63 Å [symmetry code: (iii) −x + 1, −y + 2, −z + 1], resulting in several atypically short inter­molecular distances. This situation could not be improved by the application of anti-bumping restraints. Moreover, the region of the disordered B chain also contained significant residual electron-density peaks, with Δρmax = 1.02 e Å−3 at a distance of 2.64 Å from C23iii.

Additionally, energy calculations carried out on the four theoretical ordered crystal structures containing optimized mol­ecular geometries representing possible A/B combinations indicated a significant disadvantage associated with the minor B com­ponent (see Fig. S7 of the supporting information).

The search for a better model then let us consider the possibility of a third disorder com­ponent B3 of the chain (–C24—O25—C26—C27), which results from the rotation of the arene ring about the C13—C18⋯C21—C28 axis by ap­proximately 180° (see Fig. 4[link]). The geometry of the first dis­order com­ponent B1 was largely unchanged in this new three-way-split model. The main difference between B1 and the second com­ponent B2 is a 44° rotation about the C19—C24 bond (see Table S8 of the supporting information). As expected, the alternative positions of the two methyl groups lie in very close proximity, i.e. C27⋯C27A = 0.371 (16) Å. The final occupancies of B1, B2 and B3 were 0.597 (3), 0.223 (3) and 0.180 (2), respectively. The presence of a B3 chain in a given mol­ecule means that a particular neighbouring mol­ecule to which it is related by the inversion operation (−x + 1, −y + 2, −z + 1) must also contain the B3 con­for­mation, i.e. the B3 geometry of one mol­ecule is geometrically incom­patible with a B1 or B2 chain in the other. The refined site occupancy of 0.804 for the major A1 com­ponent is similar to the sum of the occupancies of 0.820 for B1 and B2, but it cannot be ascertained from diffraction data how the occupancies in sections A and B of the SST mol­ecule are correlated with one another. This topic was investigated further with energy calculations, discussed in the following section, which were also used to establish the viability of the obtained chain con­for­mations.

[Figure 4]
Figure 4
Detailed views of the alternative chain con­for­mations of the disorder com­ponents A1/A2 and C1/C2 (top), and B1/B2/B3 (bottom; H atoms have been omitted for clarity).

The con­for­mations C1 and C2 of the disordered cyclo­pentyl ring were analysed using PLATON (Spek, 2020View full citation). Ring-puckering parameters (Cremer & Pople, 1975View full citation) of q = 0.421 (13) Å and ϕ = 28 (2)° obtained for the major com­ponent indicate an inter­mediate geometry between C34-envelope and C31/C34-twist. The minor com­ponent (Fig. 4[link]) displays a con­for­mation between C36A-envelope and C36A/C35A-twist, resulting in ring-puckering parameters of q = 0.338 (19) Å and ϕ = 279 (3)°.

3.3. Energy calculations

To further investigate the disorder in the –CH2CH2CH2CH3 (section A in Scheme 1[link]) and –CH2OCH2CH3 (section B) groups, six independent ordered structural models were generated, each starting from one of the disorder sites identified in the experimental structure. These structures were then optimized (PBE-MBD*), with the experimental lattice parameters and atomic positions allowed to minimize. The minimizations revealed that the six initial models did not con­verge to a single structure. Instead, each of the possible positions for both disordered groups yielded a unique minimum on the lattice energy landscape, indicating that the disorder in the A group is not linked to the disorder in the B group, and vice versa. Each of the positions of the A and B groups was well reproduced in the PBE-MBD* structures, as shown by the overlay of experimental and PBE-MBD* con­for­mations (Fig. 5[link]).

[Figure 5]
Figure 5
Overlay of the experimental con­for­mations (coloured by element) with the con­for­mations observed in the optimized structures (in green). Rmsd1 and intra­molecular energy differences (ΔEintra) were calculated at the B3LYP/6-31G(d,p) level of theory. ΔEintra values are reported relative to the lowest energy among the six con­for­mations.

The intra­molecular energy differences (ΔEintra) for the six con­for­mations were estimated at the B3LYP/6-31G(d,p) level of theory. A2B1 was identified as the lowest-energy con­for­mation among the six (calculated in the gas phase), although it was only 2.00 kJ mol−1 lower than A1B1. Therefore, the energy difference between the two A chain orientations is relatively small com­pared to the energy differences between the B orientations, which were estimated to be in the range 5–11 kJ mol−1.

Less favourable intra­molecular energies can be offset by stronger inter­molecular inter­actions within the crystal structure. A com­parison of the lattice energies (PBE-MBD*) of the six distinct orientations (Table 3[link]) in the SST structure revealed that the three structures adopting the A1 orientation are lower in energy than the three A2-based structures. In the experimental structure, the disorder ratio was refined to 0.45:0.55, with A2 being only slightly favoured. Adding the B orientations to the com­parison revealed that B1 is favoured over B2 and B3, which is clearly reflected in the disorder ratio of 0.60 for B1, com­pared to 0.22 and 0.18 for the remaining two orientations. Overall, the structure optimizations revealed that A1B1 might be the most stable of the six models based on lattice energy calculations. However, with the exception of the A2B2 model, all are within 10 kJ mol−1. The calculations de­mon­strate that numerous orientations are feasible for forming low-energy structures, and adding entropic contributions is expected to further stabilize the structures. This helps rationalize the high tendency toward disorder in the SST structure. All orientations were well reproduced in the models, with the B3 orientation, a minor orientation involving a 180° flip of the bi­phenyl Ph–Ph dihedral, showing a slightly higher rmds15 value than the other structures (Table 3[link]).

Table 3
Lattice energy differences (PBE-MBD*, kJ mol−1) among the six ordered STU structure models and rmsd15 values (Å)

Structure ΔElatt rmsd15 Structure ΔElatt rmsd15
A1B1 0.00 0.15 A2B1 7.23 0.24
A1B2 6.45 0.12 A2B2 11.67 0.18
A1B3 6.01 0.39 A2B3 8.88 0.39

In addition to calculating the lattice energy differences between the models, we also com­puted the pairwise inter­molecular inter­action energies for the PBE-MBD* structures. The six optimized structure models exhibit identical packing arrangements (Fig. 6[link]), differing only in the torsional variations of the two flexible groups. The R22(8) dimer motif was identified as the strongest pairwise inter­molecular inter­action, with an inter­action energy between −127.8 and −150.1 kJ mol−1. This inter­action is stabilized not only by significant electrostatic contributions but also by dispersion forces. Sparsentan, which has a single hy­dro­gen-bond donor group, but multiple aromatic rings and flexible alkyl chains, allows for the formation of relatively strong aromatic inter­actions and close contacts. The second and third strongest inter­actions fall within the −92.5 to −72.9 kJ mol−1 range (Tables S3–S6 of the supporting information) and, despite their strength, they do not involve classical strong hy­dro­gen bonds, highlighting the crucial role of dispersion forces in stabilizing the crystal lattice. The fact that each of the six models remained at a local minimum without transitioning to another arrangement sug­gests a potential for disorder, often seen in com­puted crystal energy landscapes where major and minor com­ponents appear as separate structures (Hunnisett et al., 2024View full citation). The applied lattice energy minimization models do not account for entropic contributions, which are expected to stabilize the structure and, therefore, support the experimentally observed disorder.

[Figure 6]
Figure 6
Energy framework diagrams (total energy), illustrating that all six tested sparsentan models result in the same order of the strong pairwise inter­actions. The energy scale factor is 50. Stabilizing contacts are shown in blue and the thickness corresponds to the strength. Pairwise inter­action energies less than 20 kJ mol−1 and H atoms have been omitted for clarity. The packing diagrams are displayed along the respective crystallographic a axes.

3.4. Characterization of the crystalline phase of SST

3.4.1. Powder X-ray diffraction (PXRD)

The experimental room-tem­per­a­ture PXRD pattern of a sample of SST obtained via cooling crystallization from aceto­nitrile matches a corresponding pattern (193 K) calculated with Mercury (Macrae et al., 2020View full citation) from the crystal structure data (Fig. 7[link]). Slight differences in peak positions are due to different tem­per­a­ture conditions.

[Figure 7]
Figure 7
Experimental PXRD pattern of SST (top) and a simulated pattern derived from the single-crystal structure (bottom).
3.4.2. Thermal analysis

To investigate the thermal properties of the title com­pound, including its glass transition tem­per­a­ture (Tg), the differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) analysis was performed as a heating–cooling–heating cycle. The transition tem­per­a­ture Tg was determined using a melt–quench technique. The material was first heated beyond its melting point and then cooled rapidly to trap the molten state in an amorphous form. The DSC plot (Fig. 8[link], first curve) shows a sharp endothermic peak at 140.6 ± 0.2 °C (onset), which corresponds to the melting of SST, and the TGA thermogram (Fig. 8[link]) shows a concurrent mass loss of 0.60% between 25 and 145 °C. Following the first heating, the amorphous sample was cooled to −20 °C and then reheated to 155 °C, and during this step, the glass transition was observed at Tg = 41.5 °C. This relatively low Tg is indicative of the poor physical stability of amorphous SST and a likelihood of recrystallization from the amorphous state during long-term storage.

[Figure 8]
Figure 8
DSC curves: two heating/cooling cycles (red/blue; Tg = glass transition tem­per­a­ture) and the TGA curve (black) of crystalline sparsentan.
3.4.3. FT–IR spectroscopy

The FT–IR spectra (Fig. 9[link]) of the amorphous and the crystalline forms of SST were recorded and com­pared. In the case of the crystalline form, sharp peaks were observed at 1725 (C=O), 1629 and 1484 (C=C), and 1326 and 1160 cm−1 (O=S=O). In the spectrum of the amorphous form, the corresponding peak positions are shifted by less than 20 cm−1 to lower or higher wavenumbers. Additionally, the crystalline form produces a sharp N—H stretching peak above 3000 cm−1, whilst the corresponding peak in the spectrum of the amorphous form is significantly broadened. This broadening and shifting of peaks is attributed to mol­ecular rearrangements during the amorphization process which disrupt the periodic order of the crystal lattice in the solid state (Moinuddin et al., 2020View full citation).

[Figure 9]
Figure 9
FT–IR spectra of the amorphous (red) and crystalline (black) forms of SST with assigned band positions.

4. Conclusions

In the solid state, the sparsentan mol­ecule exhibits two dis­or­der­ed chain sections (A and B), in addition to a dis­or­der­ed cyclo­pentyl ring (section C). This study demonstrates the application of com­plementary energy calculations to improve and inter­pret a com­plex disorder model. It was found that an initial disorder model for section B contained a minor-occupancy com­ponent with an unviable chain geometry. This led to the establishment of an alternative three-com­ponent disorder model for B, resulting in significantly improved structure refinement parameters. Energy calculations confirmed the viability of the three chain geometries implied by the final model for section B. In addition, these com­putations indicated that the two disordered chains of sections A and B of the mol­ecule are uncorrelated with regard to their occupancy.

Supporting information


Computing details top

2-{4-[(2-Butyl-4-oxo-1,3-diazaspiro[4.4]non-1-en-3-yl)methyl]-2-(ethoxymethyl)phenyl}-N-(4,5-dimethyl-1,2-oxazol-3-yl)benzenesulfonamide top
Crystal data top
C32H40N4O5SZ = 2
Mr = 592.74F(000) = 632
Triclinic, P1Dx = 1.270 Mg m3
a = 11.3363 (10) ÅMo Kα radiation, λ = 0.71073 Å
b = 11.8815 (8) ÅCell parameters from 4034 reflections
c = 14.0763 (10) Åθ = 2.1–27.5°
α = 98.113 (6)°µ = 0.15 mm1
β = 112.679 (8)°T = 193 K
γ = 110.711 (7)°Block, colourless
V = 1549.4 (2) Å30.25 × 0.25 × 0.15 mm
Data collection top
Rigaku Xcalibur Gemini ultra
diffractometer with a Ruby detector
6837 independent reflections
Radiation source: fine-focus sealed X-ray tube, Enhance (Mo) X-ray Source4250 reflections with I > 2σ(I)
Graphite monochromatorRint = 0.042
Detector resolution: 10.3575 pixels mm-1θmax = 27.1°, θmin = 1.9°
ω scansh = 1413
Absorption correction: multi-scan
(CrysAlis PRO; Rigaku OD, 2020)
k = 1515
Tmin = 0.921, Tmax = 1.000l = 1718
14469 measured reflections
Refinement top
Refinement on F2Secondary atom site location: difference Fourier map
Least-squares matrix: fullHydrogen site location: mixed
R[F2 > 2σ(F2)] = 0.054H atoms treated by a mixture of independent and constrained refinement
wR(F2) = 0.140 w = 1/[σ2(Fo2) + (0.0559P)2 + 0.1427P]
where P = (Fo2 + 2Fc2)/3
S = 1.03(Δ/σ)max = 0.001
6837 reflectionsΔρmax = 0.48 e Å3
528 parametersΔρmin = 0.31 e Å3
483 restraintsExtinction correction: SHELXL2014 (Sheldrick, 2015b), Fc*=kFc[1+0.001xFc2λ3/sin(2θ)]-1/4
Primary atom site location: structure-invariant direct methodsExtinction coefficient: 0.0105 (14)
Special details top

Geometry. All esds (except the esd in the dihedral angle between two l.s. planes) are estimated using the full covariance matrix. The cell esds are taken into account individually in the estimation of esds in distances, angles and torsion angles; correlations between esds in cell parameters are only used when they are defined by crystal symmetry. An approximate (isotropic) treatment of cell esds is used for estimating esds involving l.s. planes.

Fractional atomic coordinates and isotropic or equivalent isotropic displacement parameters (Å2) top
xyzUiso*/UeqOcc. (<1)
O10.00778 (17)0.41650 (17)0.14189 (13)0.0480 (5)
N20.0841 (2)0.4553 (2)0.25702 (15)0.0449 (5)
C30.2017 (2)0.4463 (2)0.27558 (17)0.0324 (5)
C40.2117 (2)0.4057 (2)0.18051 (18)0.0349 (5)
C50.0865 (2)0.3879 (2)0.10009 (18)0.0392 (6)
N60.30571 (19)0.47637 (18)0.38134 (14)0.0334 (4)
H60.3925 (14)0.491 (2)0.394 (2)0.053 (8)*
S70.29254 (6)0.51760 (5)0.49058 (4)0.03276 (17)
O80.16728 (16)0.42267 (15)0.48335 (13)0.0428 (4)
C90.3295 (3)0.3851 (3)0.1726 (2)0.0555 (7)
H9A0.30590.35660.09600.083*
H9B0.34270.32030.20570.083*
H9C0.41790.46490.21100.083*
C100.0209 (3)0.3430 (3)0.02031 (19)0.0549 (7)
H10A0.08640.32480.04190.082*
H10B0.00200.40900.04860.082*
H10C0.06910.26560.05000.082*
O110.42842 (15)0.54477 (15)0.57733 (12)0.0394 (4)
C120.2703 (2)0.6577 (2)0.49445 (16)0.0313 (5)
C130.3465 (2)0.7583 (2)0.46804 (17)0.0340 (5)
C140.3132 (2)0.8603 (2)0.4713 (2)0.0456 (6)
H140.35870.92790.44960.055*
C150.2158 (3)0.8659 (3)0.5053 (2)0.0511 (7)
H150.19670.93760.50800.061*
C160.1460 (2)0.7684 (2)0.5353 (2)0.0444 (6)
H160.08120.77380.56090.053*
C170.1709 (2)0.6631 (2)0.52787 (18)0.0373 (5)
H170.12030.59390.54560.045*
C180.4645 (2)0.7643 (2)0.44320 (17)0.0321 (5)
C190.4541 (2)0.7587 (2)0.34031 (18)0.0359 (5)
H190.36930.75010.28240.043*0.196 (5)
C200.5692 (2)0.7658 (2)0.32386 (18)0.0370 (5)
H200.56060.75890.25320.044*
C210.6961 (2)0.7827 (2)0.40713 (18)0.0338 (5)
C220.7064 (2)0.7918 (2)0.50938 (17)0.0337 (5)
H220.79300.80450.56800.040*
C230.5928 (2)0.7827 (2)0.52734 (18)0.0348 (5)
H230.60200.78910.59810.042*0.804 (5)
C240.3237 (6)0.7510 (7)0.2442 (8)0.0442 (9)0.597 (3)
H24A0.31680.70700.17560.053*0.597 (3)
H24B0.23640.69910.24790.053*0.597 (3)
O250.3283 (3)0.8716 (3)0.2413 (3)0.0473 (9)0.597 (3)
C260.4243 (6)0.9416 (6)0.2061 (5)0.0531 (13)0.597 (3)
H26A0.39700.89320.13160.064*0.597 (3)
H26B0.52260.95680.25500.064*0.597 (3)
C270.418 (2)1.0650 (11)0.2077 (15)0.074 (4)0.597 (3)
H27A0.32181.04910.15600.111*0.597 (3)
H27B0.48741.11640.18710.111*0.597 (3)
H27C0.44111.11050.28090.111*0.597 (3)
C24A0.3197 (13)0.7516 (18)0.247 (2)0.0442 (9)0.223 (3)
H24C0.26490.66550.19290.053*0.223 (3)
H24D0.25800.76590.27680.053*0.223 (3)
O25A0.3552 (10)0.8435 (8)0.1949 (6)0.048 (2)0.223 (3)
C26A0.4003 (17)0.9690 (11)0.2589 (11)0.058 (3)0.223 (3)
H26C0.48120.99110.33120.069*0.223 (3)
H26D0.32100.97470.26950.069*0.223 (3)
C27A0.445 (7)1.059 (3)0.202 (4)0.10 (2)0.223 (3)
H27D0.53051.05970.19890.156*0.223 (3)
H27E0.46721.14440.24160.156*0.223 (3)
H27F0.36781.03160.12790.156*0.223 (3)
C24B0.6216 (14)0.8239 (10)0.6481 (7)0.046 (3)0.180 (2)
H24E0.53810.76680.65370.055*0.180 (2)
H24F0.70540.81330.69520.055*0.180 (2)
O25B0.6473 (10)0.9521 (9)0.6873 (7)0.062 (3)0.180 (2)
C26B0.661 (2)0.989 (2)0.7931 (11)0.084 (7)0.180 (2)
H26E0.72061.08150.82830.101*0.180 (2)
H26F0.70850.94550.83830.101*0.180 (2)
C27B0.517 (3)0.953 (5)0.785 (3)0.102 (15)0.180 (2)
H27G0.46670.98870.73380.153*0.180 (2)
H27H0.52680.98670.85640.153*0.180 (2)
H27I0.46260.86030.75830.153*0.180 (2)
C280.8235 (2)0.7896 (2)0.39342 (19)0.0409 (6)
H28A0.91070.86000.45520.049*
H28B0.83140.70970.39710.049*
N290.81986 (19)0.80880 (18)0.29298 (15)0.0366 (5)
C300.8737 (2)0.9260 (2)0.28282 (19)0.0366 (5)
C310.8470 (3)0.9017 (2)0.1664 (2)0.0488 (6)
N320.7736 (3)0.7646 (2)0.11856 (17)0.0565 (6)
C330.7617 (3)0.7183 (2)0.1919 (2)0.0464 (6)
C340.7501 (9)0.9575 (11)0.1012 (14)0.076 (4)0.571 (18)
H34A0.70200.91250.02210.091*0.571 (18)
H34B0.67690.95310.12440.091*0.571 (18)
C350.8569 (12)1.0950 (8)0.1302 (9)0.087 (3)0.571 (18)
H35A0.81941.13300.07440.104*0.571 (18)
H35B0.87951.14730.20180.104*0.571 (18)
C360.9880 (14)1.0840 (10)0.1331 (15)0.120 (5)0.571 (18)
H36A0.99111.08810.06420.144*0.571 (18)
H36B1.07611.15470.19380.144*0.571 (18)
C370.9781 (9)0.9583 (10)0.1483 (12)0.056 (3)0.571 (18)
H37A1.06560.97100.21190.068*0.571 (18)
H37B0.96570.90140.08290.068*0.571 (18)
C34A0.7726 (14)0.9806 (15)0.1167 (18)0.063 (3)0.429 (18)
H34C0.68160.92480.04990.075*0.429 (18)
H34D0.75131.02350.16900.075*0.429 (18)
C35A0.8720 (15)1.0774 (15)0.0901 (16)0.103 (5)0.429 (18)
H35C0.86551.15860.10300.124*0.429 (18)
H35D0.85071.04610.01360.124*0.429 (18)
C36A1.0181 (13)1.0931 (10)0.1682 (10)0.063 (3)0.429 (18)
H36C1.08631.12370.13930.076*0.429 (18)
H36D1.05561.15510.23990.076*0.429 (18)
C37A0.9983 (11)0.9658 (15)0.1786 (16)0.063 (4)0.429 (18)
H37C1.07050.97380.25040.075*0.429 (18)
H37D1.00670.91600.12100.075*0.429 (18)
O380.93176 (19)1.02622 (17)0.35434 (14)0.0521 (5)
C390.6958 (7)0.5796 (3)0.1755 (6)0.0643 (9)0.804 (5)
H39A0.63930.56350.21530.077*0.804 (5)
H39B0.62870.53410.09720.077*0.804 (5)
C400.7963 (3)0.5268 (3)0.2108 (3)0.0489 (10)0.804 (5)
H40A0.86220.57080.28940.059*0.804 (5)
H40B0.85400.54400.17200.059*0.804 (5)
C410.7258 (5)0.3833 (4)0.1911 (4)0.0616 (11)0.804 (5)
H41A0.80100.35700.22690.074*0.804 (5)
H41B0.66230.36500.22510.074*0.804 (5)
C420.6397 (7)0.3055 (6)0.0718 (5)0.089 (2)0.804 (5)
H42A0.56060.32640.03680.134*0.804 (5)
H42B0.60150.21490.06420.134*0.804 (5)
H42C0.70120.32480.03700.134*0.804 (5)
C39A0.686 (3)0.5810 (8)0.178 (2)0.0643 (9)0.196 (5)
H39C0.71890.57180.25120.077*0.196 (5)
H39D0.58320.55770.14800.077*0.196 (5)
C40A0.7002 (16)0.4884 (10)0.1112 (13)0.061 (4)0.196 (5)
H40C0.80200.52270.12830.073*0.196 (5)
H40D0.64530.48160.03450.073*0.196 (5)
C41A0.653 (3)0.3537 (13)0.1184 (17)0.060 (5)0.196 (5)
H41C0.73210.35140.18030.072*0.196 (5)
H41D0.57010.33050.13220.072*0.196 (5)
C42A0.614 (3)0.2575 (18)0.0147 (19)0.110 (9)0.196 (5)
H42D0.67940.29490.01410.164*0.196 (5)
H42E0.51580.23360.03910.164*0.196 (5)
H42F0.62150.18180.03050.164*0.196 (5)
Atomic displacement parameters (Å2) top
U11U22U33U12U13U23
O10.0417 (9)0.0646 (12)0.0406 (10)0.0347 (9)0.0127 (8)0.0158 (8)
N20.0399 (11)0.0612 (14)0.0350 (11)0.0315 (11)0.0121 (9)0.0115 (10)
C30.0317 (11)0.0316 (12)0.0369 (13)0.0185 (10)0.0147 (10)0.0115 (10)
C40.0365 (12)0.0328 (13)0.0393 (13)0.0185 (10)0.0182 (10)0.0127 (10)
C50.0438 (13)0.0387 (14)0.0418 (13)0.0248 (11)0.0201 (12)0.0145 (11)
N60.0298 (10)0.0410 (11)0.0337 (10)0.0218 (9)0.0135 (9)0.0118 (8)
S70.0339 (3)0.0411 (4)0.0370 (3)0.0254 (3)0.0197 (3)0.0183 (3)
O80.0435 (9)0.0437 (10)0.0609 (11)0.0258 (8)0.0332 (8)0.0287 (8)
C90.0464 (15)0.080 (2)0.0410 (15)0.0344 (15)0.0199 (12)0.0080 (13)
C100.0645 (17)0.0577 (18)0.0396 (14)0.0355 (15)0.0147 (13)0.0140 (12)
O110.0404 (9)0.0557 (11)0.0350 (8)0.0339 (8)0.0172 (7)0.0191 (7)
C120.0292 (11)0.0372 (13)0.0325 (12)0.0211 (10)0.0133 (9)0.0121 (10)
C130.0284 (11)0.0383 (13)0.0394 (13)0.0200 (10)0.0158 (10)0.0113 (10)
C140.0400 (13)0.0387 (15)0.0682 (17)0.0228 (12)0.0290 (13)0.0209 (13)
C150.0457 (14)0.0442 (16)0.0774 (19)0.0306 (13)0.0332 (14)0.0176 (14)
C160.0381 (13)0.0493 (16)0.0596 (16)0.0292 (12)0.0280 (12)0.0151 (12)
C170.0337 (12)0.0452 (15)0.0427 (13)0.0234 (11)0.0211 (10)0.0156 (11)
C180.0316 (11)0.0306 (12)0.0424 (13)0.0185 (10)0.0201 (10)0.0139 (10)
C190.0324 (12)0.0384 (13)0.0409 (13)0.0189 (10)0.0176 (10)0.0147 (10)
C200.0409 (13)0.0451 (14)0.0372 (13)0.0257 (11)0.0220 (11)0.0185 (11)
C210.0365 (12)0.0350 (13)0.0441 (13)0.0214 (10)0.0249 (11)0.0202 (10)
C220.0288 (11)0.0425 (14)0.0371 (12)0.0203 (10)0.0163 (10)0.0191 (10)
C230.0329 (12)0.0410 (14)0.0379 (12)0.0207 (10)0.0189 (10)0.0153 (10)
C240.0360 (16)0.054 (2)0.0436 (18)0.0238 (14)0.0144 (14)0.0201 (15)
O250.0471 (19)0.062 (3)0.053 (2)0.0366 (18)0.0268 (17)0.0335 (19)
C260.060 (3)0.049 (4)0.057 (3)0.027 (3)0.028 (3)0.025 (3)
C270.112 (10)0.072 (6)0.074 (7)0.056 (7)0.057 (7)0.042 (5)
C24A0.0360 (16)0.054 (2)0.0436 (18)0.0238 (14)0.0144 (14)0.0201 (15)
O25A0.050 (5)0.062 (6)0.042 (5)0.029 (5)0.023 (4)0.029 (4)
C26A0.052 (8)0.054 (7)0.070 (9)0.028 (7)0.027 (7)0.019 (6)
C27A0.10 (3)0.071 (15)0.08 (2)0.00 (2)0.018 (18)0.038 (17)
C24B0.040 (7)0.057 (8)0.055 (8)0.030 (7)0.028 (6)0.021 (6)
O25B0.052 (6)0.063 (6)0.061 (6)0.022 (5)0.028 (5)0.003 (5)
C26B0.081 (13)0.100 (18)0.056 (10)0.045 (13)0.026 (11)0.009 (11)
C27B0.102 (18)0.13 (3)0.058 (18)0.05 (2)0.046 (16)0.015 (17)
C280.0438 (13)0.0577 (16)0.0488 (14)0.0345 (12)0.0319 (12)0.0314 (12)
N290.0428 (11)0.0412 (12)0.0424 (11)0.0239 (9)0.0287 (9)0.0198 (9)
C300.0374 (12)0.0419 (15)0.0456 (14)0.0253 (11)0.0251 (11)0.0185 (12)
C310.0663 (17)0.0475 (16)0.0544 (16)0.0304 (14)0.0410 (14)0.0260 (13)
N320.0764 (16)0.0533 (15)0.0528 (13)0.0270 (12)0.0441 (12)0.0176 (11)
C330.0554 (15)0.0426 (15)0.0570 (16)0.0243 (13)0.0385 (13)0.0173 (12)
C340.088 (5)0.078 (6)0.061 (6)0.046 (5)0.022 (5)0.037 (5)
C350.141 (7)0.072 (5)0.088 (6)0.068 (5)0.064 (5)0.052 (4)
C360.122 (8)0.097 (7)0.154 (11)0.037 (6)0.071 (8)0.086 (7)
C370.087 (4)0.053 (4)0.067 (7)0.033 (4)0.067 (5)0.032 (4)
C34A0.088 (6)0.060 (7)0.051 (7)0.038 (6)0.034 (6)0.028 (5)
C35A0.098 (7)0.085 (8)0.109 (9)0.019 (6)0.041 (7)0.062 (7)
C36A0.098 (6)0.052 (5)0.049 (5)0.028 (4)0.046 (4)0.023 (3)
C37A0.093 (5)0.060 (6)0.052 (7)0.027 (4)0.056 (5)0.022 (4)
O380.0614 (11)0.0445 (11)0.0570 (11)0.0263 (9)0.0320 (9)0.0144 (9)
C390.073 (2)0.0480 (18)0.086 (2)0.0241 (16)0.0522 (18)0.0228 (15)
C400.0466 (19)0.047 (2)0.055 (2)0.0208 (16)0.0263 (17)0.0176 (16)
C410.069 (3)0.056 (2)0.083 (3)0.037 (2)0.047 (2)0.033 (2)
C420.083 (4)0.060 (4)0.103 (5)0.028 (4)0.036 (4)0.003 (3)
C39A0.073 (2)0.0480 (18)0.086 (2)0.0241 (16)0.0522 (18)0.0228 (15)
C40A0.059 (8)0.042 (7)0.085 (10)0.027 (6)0.037 (7)0.011 (6)
C41A0.073 (11)0.058 (8)0.057 (11)0.036 (10)0.029 (10)0.027 (8)
C42A0.093 (15)0.072 (12)0.127 (19)0.032 (13)0.044 (16)0.029 (12)
Geometric parameters (Å, º) top
O1—C51.349 (3)C26B—C27B1.486 (15)
O1—N21.419 (2)C26B—H26E0.9900
N2—C31.302 (3)C26B—H26F0.9900
C3—N61.390 (3)C27B—H27G0.9800
C3—C41.418 (3)C27B—H27H0.9800
C4—C51.350 (3)C27B—H27I0.9800
C4—C91.481 (3)C28—N291.451 (3)
C5—C101.484 (3)C28—H28A0.9900
N6—S71.626 (2)C28—H28B0.9900
N6—H60.875 (10)N29—C301.362 (3)
S7—O81.4221 (16)N29—C331.399 (3)
S7—O111.4334 (15)C30—O381.209 (3)
S7—C121.766 (2)C30—C311.510 (3)
C9—H9A0.9800C31—N321.448 (3)
C9—H9B0.9800C31—C371.537 (6)
C9—H9C0.9800C31—C37A1.538 (7)
C10—H10A0.9800C31—C34A1.540 (7)
C10—H10B0.9800C31—C341.549 (6)
C10—H10C0.9800N32—C331.266 (3)
C12—C171.395 (3)C33—C391.489 (4)
C12—C131.399 (3)C33—C39A1.492 (8)
C13—C141.391 (3)C34—C351.528 (7)
C13—C181.489 (3)C34—H34A0.9900
C14—C151.379 (3)C34—H34B0.9900
C14—H140.9500C35—C361.522 (7)
C15—C161.376 (3)C35—H35A0.9900
C15—H150.9500C35—H35B0.9900
C16—C171.376 (3)C36—C371.510 (6)
C16—H160.9500C36—H36A0.9900
C17—H170.9500C36—H36B0.9900
C18—C231.392 (3)C37—H37A0.9900
C18—C191.397 (3)C37—H37B0.9900
C19—C201.387 (3)C34A—C35A1.504 (12)
C19—C241.534 (4)C34A—H34C0.9900
C19—C24A1.544 (8)C34A—H34D0.9900
C19—H190.9500C35A—C36A1.518 (12)
C20—C211.383 (3)C35A—H35C0.9900
C20—H200.9500C35A—H35D0.9900
C21—C221.384 (3)C36A—C37A1.486 (11)
C21—C281.505 (3)C36A—H36C0.9900
C22—C231.376 (3)C36A—H36D0.9900
C22—H220.9500C37A—H37C0.9900
C23—C24B1.568 (8)C37A—H37D0.9900
C23—H230.9500C39—C401.447 (7)
C24—O251.422 (7)C39—H39A0.9900
C24—H24A0.9900C39—H39B0.9900
C24—H24B0.9900C40—C411.535 (4)
O25—C261.418 (5)C40—H40A0.9900
C26—C271.489 (13)C40—H40B0.9900
C26—H26A0.9900C41—C421.512 (6)
C26—H26B0.9900C41—H41A0.9900
C27—H27A0.9800C41—H41B0.9900
C27—H27B0.9800C42—H42A0.9800
C27—H27C0.9800C42—H42B0.9800
C24A—O25A1.428 (9)C42—H42C0.9800
C24A—H24C0.9900C39A—C40A1.435 (10)
C24A—H24D0.9900C39A—H39C0.9900
O25A—C26A1.422 (8)C39A—H39D0.9900
C26A—C27A1.487 (16)C40A—C41A1.529 (10)
C26A—H26C0.9900C40A—H40C0.9900
C26A—H26D0.9900C40A—H40D0.9900
C27A—H27D0.9800C41A—C42A1.516 (11)
C27A—H27E0.9800C41A—H41C0.9900
C27A—H27F0.9800C41A—H41D0.9900
C24B—O25B1.427 (8)C42A—H42D0.9800
C24B—H24E0.9900C42A—H42E0.9800
C24B—H24F0.9900C42A—H42F0.9800
O25B—C26B1.422 (9)
C5—O1—N2109.03 (16)C26B—C27B—H27I109.5
C3—N2—O1103.49 (18)H27G—C27B—H27I109.5
N2—C3—N6120.7 (2)H27H—C27B—H27I109.5
N2—C3—C4114.27 (19)N29—C28—C21115.00 (17)
N6—C3—C4125.0 (2)N29—C28—H28A108.5
C5—C4—C3102.7 (2)C21—C28—H28A108.5
C5—C4—C9129.1 (2)N29—C28—H28B108.5
C3—C4—C9128.1 (2)C21—C28—H28B108.5
O1—C5—C4110.5 (2)H28A—C28—H28B107.5
O1—C5—C10116.2 (2)C30—N29—C33107.80 (18)
C4—C5—C10133.3 (2)C30—N29—C28123.1 (2)
C3—N6—S7125.38 (16)C33—N29—C28129.1 (2)
C3—N6—H6119.6 (17)O38—C30—N29125.7 (2)
S7—N6—H6113.7 (17)O38—C30—C31129.0 (2)
O8—S7—O11118.46 (9)N29—C30—C31105.3 (2)
O8—S7—N6109.65 (10)N32—C31—C30104.82 (18)
O11—S7—N6103.87 (9)N32—C31—C37111.0 (5)
O8—S7—C12107.07 (10)C30—C31—C37117.0 (6)
O11—S7—C12109.99 (10)N32—C31—C37A115.5 (7)
N6—S7—C12107.35 (10)C30—C31—C37A103.0 (8)
C4—C9—H9A109.5N32—C31—C34A118.9 (8)
C4—C9—H9B109.5C30—C31—C34A108.1 (9)
H9A—C9—H9B109.5C37A—C31—C34A105.2 (7)
C4—C9—H9C109.5N32—C31—C34108.5 (5)
H9A—C9—H9C109.5C30—C31—C34113.1 (7)
H9B—C9—H9C109.5C37—C31—C34102.4 (5)
C5—C10—H10A109.5C33—N32—C31107.6 (2)
C5—C10—H10B109.5N32—C33—N29114.5 (2)
H10A—C10—H10B109.5N32—C33—C39123.9 (3)
C5—C10—H10C109.5N29—C33—C39121.6 (3)
H10A—C10—H10C109.5N32—C33—C39A126.3 (10)
H10B—C10—H10C109.5N29—C33—C39A119.2 (9)
C17—C12—C13121.1 (2)C35—C34—C31102.3 (5)
C17—C12—S7115.07 (17)C35—C34—H34A111.3
C13—C12—S7123.78 (17)C31—C34—H34A111.3
C14—C13—C12116.9 (2)C35—C34—H34B111.3
C14—C13—C18119.4 (2)C31—C34—H34B111.3
C12—C13—C18123.65 (19)H34A—C34—H34B109.2
C15—C14—C13121.7 (2)C36—C35—C34103.6 (6)
C15—C14—H14119.1C36—C35—H35A111.0
C13—C14—H14119.1C34—C35—H35A111.0
C16—C15—C14120.6 (2)C36—C35—H35B111.0
C16—C15—H15119.7C34—C35—H35B111.0
C14—C15—H15119.7H35A—C35—H35B109.0
C15—C16—C17119.3 (2)C37—C36—C35107.9 (5)
C15—C16—H16120.4C37—C36—H36A110.1
C17—C16—H16120.4C35—C36—H36A110.1
C16—C17—C12120.2 (2)C37—C36—H36B110.1
C16—C17—H17119.9C35—C36—H36B110.1
C12—C17—H17119.9H36A—C36—H36B108.4
C23—C18—C19118.8 (2)C36—C37—C31105.6 (5)
C23—C18—C13118.55 (19)C36—C37—H37A110.6
C19—C18—C13122.58 (18)C31—C37—H37A110.6
C20—C19—C18119.12 (19)C36—C37—H37B110.6
C20—C19—C24117.3 (5)C31—C37—H37B110.6
C18—C19—C24123.5 (5)H37A—C37—H37B108.8
C20—C19—C24A120.0 (12)C35A—C34A—C31107.8 (8)
C18—C19—C24A120.8 (12)C35A—C34A—H34C110.2
C20—C19—H19120.4C31—C34A—H34C110.2
C18—C19—H19120.4C35A—C34A—H34D110.2
C21—C20—C19122.1 (2)C31—C34A—H34D110.2
C21—C20—H20119.0H34C—C34A—H34D108.5
C19—C20—H20119.0C34A—C35A—C36A103.0 (9)
C20—C21—C22118.2 (2)C34A—C35A—H35C111.2
C20—C21—C28124.2 (2)C36A—C35A—H35C111.2
C22—C21—C28117.64 (18)C34A—C35A—H35D111.2
C23—C22—C21120.88 (19)C36A—C35A—H35D111.2
C23—C22—H22119.6H35C—C35A—H35D109.1
C21—C22—H22119.6C37A—C36A—C35A106.5 (8)
C22—C23—C18120.9 (2)C37A—C36A—H36C110.4
C22—C23—C24B118.0 (5)C35A—C36A—H36C110.4
C18—C23—C24B119.7 (5)C37A—C36A—H36D110.4
C22—C23—H23119.5C35A—C36A—H36D110.4
C18—C23—H23119.5H36C—C36A—H36D108.6
O25—C24—C19113.6 (5)C36A—C37A—C31105.1 (8)
O25—C24—H24A108.8C36A—C37A—H37C110.7
C19—C24—H24A108.8C31—C37A—H37C110.7
O25—C24—H24B108.8C36A—C37A—H37D110.7
C19—C24—H24B108.8C31—C37A—H37D110.7
H24A—C24—H24B107.7H37C—C37A—H37D108.8
C26—O25—C24114.4 (6)C40—C39—C33114.8 (4)
O25—C26—C27108.4 (9)C40—C39—H39A108.6
O25—C26—H26A110.0C33—C39—H39A108.6
C27—C26—H26A110.0C40—C39—H39B108.6
O25—C26—H26B110.0C33—C39—H39B108.6
C27—C26—H26B110.0H39A—C39—H39B107.5
H26A—C26—H26B108.4C39—C40—C41113.9 (3)
C26—C27—H27A109.5C39—C40—H40A108.8
C26—C27—H27B109.5C41—C40—H40A108.8
H27A—C27—H27B109.5C39—C40—H40B108.8
C26—C27—H27C109.5C41—C40—H40B108.8
H27A—C27—H27C109.5H40A—C40—H40B107.7
H27B—C27—H27C109.5C42—C41—C40113.1 (4)
O25A—C24A—C19112.0 (8)C42—C41—H41A109.0
O25A—C24A—H24C109.2C40—C41—H41A109.0
C19—C24A—H24C109.2C42—C41—H41B109.0
O25A—C24A—H24D109.2C40—C41—H41B109.0
C19—C24A—H24D109.2H41A—C41—H41B107.8
H24C—C24A—H24D107.9C41—C42—H42A109.5
C26A—O25A—C24A112.7 (13)C41—C42—H42B109.5
O25A—C26A—C27A108.8 (16)H42A—C42—H42B109.5
O25A—C26A—H26C109.9C41—C42—H42C109.5
C27A—C26A—H26C109.9H42A—C42—H42C109.5
O25A—C26A—H26D109.9H42B—C42—H42C109.5
C27A—C26A—H26D109.9C40A—C39A—C33119.7 (10)
H26C—C26A—H26D108.3C40A—C39A—H39C107.4
C26A—C27A—H27D109.5C33—C39A—H39C107.4
C26A—C27A—H27E109.5C40A—C39A—H39D107.4
H27D—C27A—H27E109.5C33—C39A—H39D107.4
C26A—C27A—H27F109.5H39C—C39A—H39D106.9
H27D—C27A—H27F109.5C39A—C40A—C41A119.2 (11)
H27E—C27A—H27F109.5C39A—C40A—H40C107.5
O25B—C24B—C23113.4 (8)C41A—C40A—H40C107.5
O25B—C24B—H24E108.9C39A—C40A—H40D107.5
C23—C24B—H24E108.9C41A—C40A—H40D107.5
O25B—C24B—H24F108.9H40C—C40A—H40D107.0
C23—C24B—H24F108.9C42A—C41A—C40A111.7 (13)
H24E—C24B—H24F107.7C42A—C41A—H41C109.3
C26B—O25B—C24B114.6 (12)C40A—C41A—H41C109.3
O25B—C26B—C27B109.3 (15)C42A—C41A—H41D109.3
O25B—C26B—H26E109.8C40A—C41A—H41D109.3
C27B—C26B—H26E109.8H41C—C41A—H41D107.9
O25B—C26B—H26F109.8C41A—C42A—H42D109.5
C27B—C26B—H26F109.8C41A—C42A—H42E109.5
H26E—C26B—H26F108.3H42D—C42A—H42E109.5
C26B—C27B—H27G109.5C41A—C42A—H42F109.5
C26B—C27B—H27H109.5H42D—C42A—H42F109.5
H27G—C27B—H27H109.5H42E—C42A—H42F109.5
C5—O1—N2—C30.4 (2)C18—C19—C24A—O25A130.2 (17)
O1—N2—C3—N6179.66 (18)C19—C24A—O25A—C26A74 (2)
O1—N2—C3—C40.9 (2)C24A—O25A—C26A—C27A176 (3)
N2—C3—C4—C51.0 (3)C22—C23—C24B—O25B95.0 (9)
N6—C3—C4—C5179.5 (2)C18—C23—C24B—O25B71.6 (10)
N2—C3—C4—C9179.7 (2)C23—C24B—O25B—C26B174.6 (11)
N6—C3—C4—C90.9 (4)C24B—O25B—C26B—C27B86 (3)
N2—O1—C5—C40.2 (3)C20—C21—C28—N2914.6 (3)
N2—O1—C5—C10178.92 (19)C22—C21—C28—N29166.5 (2)
C3—C4—C5—O10.7 (2)C21—C28—N29—C3089.5 (3)
C9—C4—C5—O1179.3 (2)C21—C28—N29—C3388.9 (3)
C3—C4—C5—C10178.2 (3)C33—N29—C30—O38179.8 (2)
C9—C4—C5—C100.4 (4)C28—N29—C30—O381.1 (3)
N2—C3—N6—S73.2 (3)C33—N29—C30—C311.1 (2)
C4—C3—N6—S7177.40 (17)C28—N29—C30—C31179.75 (19)
C3—N6—S7—O855.5 (2)O38—C30—C31—N32179.8 (2)
C3—N6—S7—O11176.99 (18)N29—C30—C31—N321.1 (2)
C3—N6—S7—C1260.5 (2)N29—C30—C31—C37122.2 (4)
O8—S7—C12—C1721.51 (19)O38—C30—C31—C37A59.0 (7)
O11—S7—C12—C17108.44 (17)N29—C30—C31—C37A120.1 (6)
N6—S7—C12—C17139.18 (16)O38—C30—C31—C34A52.0 (6)
O8—S7—C12—C13159.41 (17)N29—C30—C31—C34A128.9 (6)
O11—S7—C12—C1370.64 (19)N29—C30—C31—C34119.2 (4)
N6—S7—C12—C1341.7 (2)C30—C31—N32—C330.7 (3)
C17—C12—C13—C143.2 (3)C37—C31—N32—C33126.4 (6)
S7—C12—C13—C14177.76 (17)C37A—C31—N32—C33111.8 (8)
C17—C12—C13—C18173.3 (2)C34A—C31—N32—C33121.6 (8)
S7—C12—C13—C185.7 (3)C34—C31—N32—C33121.9 (7)
C12—C13—C14—C153.8 (3)C31—N32—C33—N290.1 (3)
C18—C13—C14—C15172.9 (2)C31—N32—C33—C39178.1 (4)
C13—C14—C15—C161.2 (4)C31—N32—C33—C39A176.5 (13)
C14—C15—C16—C172.0 (4)C30—N29—C33—N320.6 (3)
C15—C16—C17—C122.6 (4)C28—N29—C33—N32179.2 (2)
C13—C12—C17—C160.1 (3)C30—N29—C33—C39178.9 (3)
S7—C12—C17—C16179.19 (18)C28—N29—C33—C392.5 (5)
C14—C13—C18—C23106.7 (2)C30—N29—C33—C39A176.0 (13)
C12—C13—C18—C2369.7 (3)C28—N29—C33—C39A2.6 (13)
C14—C13—C18—C1969.9 (3)N32—C31—C34—C35159.5 (8)
C12—C13—C18—C19113.7 (2)C30—C31—C34—C3584.6 (10)
C23—C18—C19—C202.9 (3)C37—C31—C34—C3542.1 (13)
C13—C18—C19—C20179.5 (2)C31—C34—C35—C3638.6 (16)
C23—C18—C19—C24174.2 (3)C34—C35—C36—C3720.6 (16)
C13—C18—C19—C242.4 (4)C35—C36—C37—C315.8 (14)
C23—C18—C19—C24A173.9 (8)N32—C31—C37—C36145.1 (8)
C13—C18—C19—C24A2.7 (9)C30—C31—C37—C3694.7 (8)
C18—C19—C20—C212.2 (3)C34—C31—C37—C3629.5 (11)
C24—C19—C20—C21175.1 (4)N32—C31—C34A—C35A125.5 (15)
C24A—C19—C20—C21174.6 (9)C30—C31—C34A—C35A115.3 (16)
C19—C20—C21—C220.3 (3)C37A—C31—C34A—C35A6 (2)
C19—C20—C21—C28179.3 (2)C31—C34A—C35A—C36A25 (2)
C20—C21—C22—C230.8 (3)C34A—C35A—C36A—C37A36 (2)
C28—C21—C22—C23178.2 (2)C35A—C36A—C37A—C3132.4 (14)
C21—C22—C23—C180.1 (3)N32—C31—C37A—C36A149.4 (8)
C21—C22—C23—C24B166.5 (5)C30—C31—C37A—C36A97.0 (10)
C19—C18—C23—C221.8 (3)C34A—C31—C37A—C36A16.1 (16)
C13—C18—C23—C22178.5 (2)N32—C33—C39—C4097.0 (5)
C19—C18—C23—C24B164.4 (5)N29—C33—C39—C4081.1 (5)
C13—C18—C23—C24B12.3 (6)C33—C39—C40—C41178.9 (4)
C20—C19—C24—O2591.0 (9)C39—C40—C41—C4267.0 (5)
C18—C19—C24—O2586.1 (7)N32—C33—C39A—C40A41 (3)
C19—C24—O25—C2675.1 (10)N29—C33—C39A—C40A143.0 (19)
C24—O25—C26—C27179.8 (9)C33—C39A—C40A—C41A166 (2)
C20—C19—C24A—O25A47 (2)C39A—C40A—C41A—C42A155 (2)
Hydrogen-bond geometry (Å, º) top
D—H···AD—HH···AD···AD—H···A
N6—H6···O11i0.88 (1)2.12 (1)2.951 (2)159 (2)
C28—H28A···O38ii0.992.403.318 (3)153
C28—H28B···O8i0.992.463.265 (3)138
Symmetry codes: (i) x+1, y+1, z+1; (ii) x+2, y+2, z+1.
Lattice energy differences (PBE-MBD*) among the six ordered STU structure models and rmsd15 values top
StructureΔElatt (kJ mol-1)rmsd15 (Å)StructureΔElatt (kJ mol-1)rmsd15 (Å)
A1B10.000.15A2B17.230.24
A1B26.450.12A2B211.670.18
A1B36.010.39A2B38.880.39
 

Acknowledgements

The financial support received for the Christian Doppler Laboratory for Advanced Crystal Engineering Strategies in Drug Development by the Austrian Federal Ministry of Economy, Energy and Tourism, the National Foundation for Research, Technology and Development and the Christian Doppler Research Association (award to Doris E. Braun) is gratefully acknowledged. Computational results presented here have been achieved using the LEO HPC infrastructure of the University of Innsbruck.

References

Return to citationBernstein, J., Davis, R. E., Shimoni, L. & Chang, N.-L. (1995). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl. 34, 1555–1573.  CrossRef CAS Web of Science Google Scholar
Return to citationBruker (1998). XP. Bruker AXS Inc., Madison, Wisconsin, USA.  Google Scholar
Return to citationClark, S. J., Segall, M. D., Pickard, C. J., Hasnip, P. J., Probert, M. I. J., Refson, K. & Payne, M. C. (2005). Z. Kristallogr. 220, 567–570.  Web of Science CrossRef CAS Google Scholar
Return to citationCremer, D. & Pople, J. A. (1975). J. Am. Chem. Soc. 97, 1354–1358.  CrossRef CAS Web of Science Google Scholar
Return to citationDesiraju, G. R. (2007). Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 46, 8342–8356.  Web of Science CrossRef CAS Google Scholar
Return to citationDiederichs, K. (2016). Methods Mol. Biol. 1320, 147–173.  CrossRef PubMed Google Scholar
Return to citationDittrich, B. (2021). IUCrJ 8, 305–318.  Web of Science CrossRef CAS PubMed IUCr Journals Google Scholar
Return to citationEtter, M. C., MacDonald, J. C. & Bernstein, J. (1990). Acta Cryst. B46, 256–262.  CrossRef ICSD CAS Web of Science IUCr Journals Google Scholar
Return to citationFrisch, M. J., Trucks, G. W., Schlegel, H. B., Scuseria, G. E., Robb, M. A., Cheeseman, J. R., Scalmani, G., Barone, V., Petersson, G. A., Nakatsuji, H., Li, X., Caricato, M., Marenich, A. V., Bloino, J., Janesko, B. G., Gomperts, R., Mennucci, B., Hratchian, H. P., Ortiz, J. V., Izmaylov, A. F., Sonnenberg, J. L., Williams-Young, D., Ding, F., Lipparini, F., Egidi, F., Goings, J., Peng, B., Petrone, A., Henderson, T., Ranasinghe, D., Zakrzewski, V. G., Gao, J., Rega, N., Zheng, G., Liang, W., Hada, M., Ehara, M., Toyota, K., Fukuda, R., Hasegawa, J., Ishida, M., Nakajima, T., Honda, Y., Kitao, O., Nakai, H., Vreven, T., Throssell, K., Montgomery, J. A. J., Peralta, J. E., Ogliaro, F., Bearpark, M. J., Heyd, J. J., Brothers, E. N., Kudin, K. N., Staroverov, V. N., Keith, T. A., Kobayashi, R., Normand, J., Raghavachari, K., Rendell, A. P., Burant, J. C., Iyengar, S. S., Tomasi, J., Cossi, M., Millam, J. M., Klene, M., Adamo, C., Cammi, R., Ochterski, J. W., Martin, R. L., Morokuma, K., Farkas, O., Foresman, J. B. & Fox, D. J. (2019). GAUSSIAN16. Revision C.01. Gaussian Inc., Wallingford, CT, USA. https://gaussian.com/Google Scholar
Return to citationGroom, C. R., Bruno, I. J., Lightfoot, M. P. & Ward, S. C. (2016). Acta Cryst. B72, 171–179.  Web of Science CrossRef IUCr Journals Google Scholar
Return to citationHunnisett, L. M., Francia, N., Nyman, J., Abraham, N. S., Aitipamula, S., Alkhidir, T., Almehairbi, M., Anelli, A., Anstine, D. M., Anthony, J. E., Arnold, J. E., Bahrami, F., Bellucci, M. A., Beran, G. J. O., Bhardwaj, R. M., Bianco, R., Bis, J. A., Boese, A. D., Bramley, J., Braun, D. E., Butler, P. W. V., Cadden, J., Carino, S., Červinka, C., Chan, E. J., Chang, C., Clarke, S. M., Coles, S. J., Cook, C. J., Cooper, R. I., Darden, T., Day, G. M., Deng, W., Dietrich, H., DiPasquale, A., Dhokale, B., van Eijck, B. P., Elsegood, M. R. J., Firaha, D., Fu, W., Fukuzawa, K., Galanakis, N., Goto, H., Greenwell, C., Guo, R., Harter, J., Helfferich, J., Hoja, J., Hone, J., Hong, R., Hušák, M., Ikabata, Y., Isayev, O., Ishaque, O., Jain, V., Jin, Y., Jing, A., Johnson, E. R., Jones, I., Jose, K. V. J., Kabova, E. A., Keates, A., Kelly, P. F., Klimeš, J., Kostková, V., Li, H., Lin, X., List, A., Liu, C., Liu, Y. M., Liu, Z., Lončarić, I., Lubach, J. W., Ludík, J., Marom, N., Matsui, H., Mattei, A., Mayo, R. A., Melkumov, J. W., Mladineo, B., Mohamed, S., Momenzadeh Abardeh, Z., Muddana, H. S., Nakayama, N., Nayal, K. S., Neumann, M. A., Nikhar, R., Obata, S., O'Connor, D., Oganov, A. R., Okuwaki, K., Otero-de-la-Roza, A., Parkin, S., Parunov, A., Podeszwa, R., Price, A. J. A., Price, L. S., Price, S. L., Probert, M. R., Pulido, A., Ramteke, G. R., Rehman, A. U., Reutzel-Edens, S. M., Rogal, J., Ross, M. J., Rumson, A. F., Sadiq, G., Saeed, Z. M., Salimi, A., Sasikumar, K., Sekharan, S., Shankland, K., Shi, B., Shi, X., Shinohara, K., Skillman, A. G., Song, H., Strasser, N., van de Streek, J., Sugden, I. J., Sun, G., Szalewicz, K., Tan, L., Tang, K., Tarczynski, F., Taylor, C. R., Tkatchenko, A., Tom, R., Touš, P., Tuckerman, M. E., Unzueta, P. A., Utsumi, Y., Vogt-Maranto, L., Weatherston, J., Wilkinson, L. J., Willacy, R. D., Wojtas, L., Woollam, G. R., Yang, Y., Yang, Z., Yonemochi, E., Yue, X., Zeng, Q., Zhou, T., Zhou, Y., Zubatyuk, R. & Cole, J. C. (2024). Acta Cryst. B80, 548–574.  Web of Science CrossRef IUCr Journals Google Scholar
Return to citationKohan, D. E., Bedard, P. W., Jenkinson, C., Hendry, B. & Komers, R. (2024). Clin. Sci. 138, 645–662.  CrossRef Google Scholar
Return to citationLinden, A. (2023). Acta Cryst. C79, 69–70.  Web of Science CrossRef IUCr Journals Google Scholar
Return to citationMacikenas, D., Ruby, K., Hulvat, J. F. & Wu, X. (2019). Int. Patent Appl. WO2020132594A1.  Google Scholar
Return to citationMackenzie, C. F., Spackman, P. R., Jayatilaka, D. & Spackman, M. A. (2017). IUCrJ 4, 575–587.  Web of Science CrossRef CAS PubMed IUCr Journals Google Scholar
Return to citationMacrae, C. F., Sovago, I., Cottrell, S. J., Galek, P. T. A., McCabe, P., Pidcock, E., Platings, M., Shields, G. P., Stevens, J. S., Towler, M. & Wood, P. A. (2020). J. Appl. Cryst. 53, 226–235.  Web of Science CrossRef CAS IUCr Journals Google Scholar
Return to citationMoinuddin, S. M., Shi, Q., Tao, J., Guo, M., Zhang, J., Xue, Q., Ruan, S. & Cai, T. (2020). AAPS PharmSciTech 21, 41.  Google Scholar
Return to citationMüller, P. (2021). IUCrJ 8, 150–151.  CrossRef IUCr Journals Google Scholar
Return to citationMurugesan, N., Gu, Z., Fadnis, L., Tellew, J. E., Baska, R. A. F., Yang, Y., Beyer, S. M., Monshizadegan, H., Dickinson, K. E., Valentine, M. T., Humphreys, W. G., Lan, S.-J., Ewing, W. R., Carlson, K. E., Kowala, M. C., Zahler, R. & Macor, J. E. (2005). J. Med. Chem. 48, 171–179.  CrossRef Google Scholar
Return to citationMurugesan, N., Tellew, J. E., Gu, Z., Kunst, B. L., Fadnis, L., Cornelius, L. A., Baska, R. A. F., Yang, Y., Beyer, S. M., Monshizadegan, H., Dickinson, K. E., Panchal, B., Valentine, M. T., Chong, S., Morrison, R. A., Carlson, K. E., Powell, J. R., Moreland, S., Barrish, J. C., Kowala, M. C. & Macor, J. E. (2002). J. Med. Chem. 45, 3829–3835.  CrossRef Google Scholar
Return to citationPerdew, J. P., Burke, K. & Ernzerhof, M. (1996). Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 3865–3868.  CrossRef PubMed CAS Web of Science Google Scholar
Return to citationRigaku OD (2020). CrysAlis PRO. Rigaku Oxford Diffraction Ltd, Yarnton, Oxfordashire, England.  Google Scholar
Return to citationSheldrick, G. M. (2015a). Acta Cryst. A71, 3–8.  Web of Science CrossRef IUCr Journals Google Scholar
Return to citationSheldrick, G. M. (2015b). Acta Cryst. C71, 3–8.  Web of Science CrossRef IUCr Journals Google Scholar
Return to citationSpackman, P. R., Turner, M. J., McKinnon, J. J., Wolff, S. K., Grimwood, D. J., Jayatilaka, D. & Spackman, M. A. (2021). J. Appl. Cryst. 54, 1006–1011.  Web of Science CrossRef CAS IUCr Journals Google Scholar
Return to citationSpek, A. L. (2020). Acta Cryst. E76, 1–11.  Web of Science CrossRef IUCr Journals Google Scholar
Return to citationSyed, Y. Y. (2023). Drugs 83, 563–568.  CrossRef Google Scholar
Return to citationTang, S. K., Davey, R. J., Sacchi, P. & Cruz-Cabeza, A. J. (2021). Chem. Sci. 12, 993–1000.  Web of Science CrossRef CAS Google Scholar
Return to citationTkatchenko, A., Alfè, D. & Kim, K. S. (2012). J. Chem. Theory Comput. 8, 4317–4322.  CrossRef Google Scholar
Return to citationVanderbilt, D. (1990). Phys. Rev. B 41, 7892–7895.  CrossRef Google Scholar
Return to citationZhang, J., Dziewanowska, Z. E., Belder, R., Henderson, I., Bogardus, J. B. & Zhang, Z. (2020). Eur. Patent Appl. EP3708163(A1).  Google Scholar

This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC-BY) Licence, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original authors and source are cited.

Journal logoSTRUCTURAL
CHEMISTRY
ISSN: 2053-2296
Follow Acta Cryst. C
Sign up for e-alerts
Follow Acta Cryst. on Twitter
Follow us on facebook
Sign up for RSS feeds