checkCIF procedure

PROC-NAME: REFNR01 Type_3

PURPOSE: To check that the ratio of _refine_ls_number_reflns and _refine_ls_number_parameters is acceptable.

PROCEDURE:
CALCULATE

S = SIN [_diffrn_reflns_theta_max] / _diffrn_radiation_wavelength

RRRT = _refine_ls_number_reflns / _reflns_number_total

RRTP = _refine_ls_number_reflns / _refine_ls_number_parameters

TEST

IF S < 0.59 OR RRRT < 0.95

IF CENTROSYMMETRIC
RRTP < 10 issue ALERT C
   "Alert C Ratio of reflections to parameters is < 10 for a centrosymmetric structure"
RRTP < 8 issue ALERT B
   "Alert B Ratio of reflections to parameters is < 8 for a centrosymmetric structure"
RRTP < 6 issue ALERT A
   "Alert A Ratio of reflections to parameters is < 6 for a centrosymmetric structure"

IF NON-CENTROSYMMETRIC
IF ZMAX > 18
RRTP < 10 issue ALERT C
   "Alert C Ratio of reflections to parameters is < 10 for a non-centrosymmetric structure, where ZMAX > 18"
RRTP < 8 issue ALERT B
   "Alert B Ratio of reflections to parameters is < 8 for a non-centrosymmetric structure, where ZMAX > 18"
RRTP < 6 issue ALERT A
   "Alert A Ratio of reflections to parameters is < 6 for a non-centrosymmetric structure, where ZMAX > 18"
ELSE
RRTP < 8 issue ALERT C
   "Alert C Ratio of reflections to parameters is < 8 for a non-centrosymmetric structure, where ZMAX < 18"
RRTP < 6 issue ALERT B
   "Alert B Ratio of reflections to parameters is < 6 for a non-centrosymmetric structure, where ZMAX < 18"
RRTP < 4 issue ALERT A
   "Alert A Ratio of reflections to parameters is < 4 for a non-centrosymmetric structure, where ZMAX < 18"
The ratio of reflections used in the refinement to refined parameters (the r/p ratio) is important for ensuring precise atomic and geometric parameters. Higher r/p ratios generally improve the precision.

It is expected that for centrosymmetric space groups, the r/p ratio should be at least 10:1. This also applies for non-centrosymmetric space groups when an element heavier than chlorine is present, because the heavy atom usually improves the diffracting power of the sample to an extent that makes it worthwhile to collect additional high angle data and thereby obtain higher r/p ratios.

For non-centrosymmetric space groups when only elements lighter than argon are present, it is expected that the r/p ratio should be at least 8:1.

If you are having difficulty obtaining a suitable r/p ratio, consider the following:
(a) Was theta(max) set high enough for the measurement? A theta(max) of 25 deg. for Mo radiation or 67 deg. for Cu radiation is the minimum requirement, but use higher theta(max) values if the crystal diffracts sufficiently.
(b) Consider using a low temperature measurement to improve the diffracting power and then collect to a higher theta(max).
(c) Check that the data are complete to your chosen theta(max) and that segments of the unique reflections are not missing. If data completeness is an issue leading to a low r/p ratio, you will receive a separate validation alert about that.
(d) Check that you are using all (or as many as feasible) of your reflection data in the refinement. If weak reflections are being omitted with a sigma threshold cutoff, such as the criterion defined under _reflns_threshold_expression (this may be particularly relevant for refinements based on F), then you should consider reducing the cutoff threshold as far as possible, or, preferably, use all reflections in the refinement.
(e) Reduce the number of refined parameters by, for example, not refining H-atoms, using restraints or constraints, or refining highly disordered or ill-behaved atoms isotropically.

Note that if you have measured data to at least sin(theta)/lambda of 0.6 (theta(max) = 25 deg. for Mo radiation; theta(max) = 67 deg. for Cu radiation) and you have used all available unique reflections in the refinement, the reflection/parameter test is not applied, because it is considered that you have measured an appropriate quantity of data and that you have made the best possible use of that data.

Also note that with light atom non-centrosymmetric structures where anomalous dispersion effects are insignificant, it is unwise to attempt to use unmerged Friedel-related reflections simply to boost the r/p ratio.


Follow IUCr Journals
Sign up for e-alerts
Follow IUCr on Twitter
Follow us on facebook
Sign up for RSS feeds